• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Shotgun Projectiles

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

kilbuck

32 Cal.
Joined
Jun 7, 2006
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
I hope to hunt deer this winter in northern Michigan using a modern 12-gauge, fluid-steel, single-barrel muzzleloading shotgun. Having read about and experimented with buckshot, I nderstand the limitations of this option. I'm looking for something with greater effective range.

Does anyone have positive experience with a 12-gauge single-projectile, such as a patched ball, skirted hollow-base ball, slug, or other load ?? that will give decent accuracy and killing power out to 50 yards?
 
I shoot a modern, cartridge slug bun in 12 ga. and it will put 5 shots in one hole at 50 yds, using iron sights, and standing off-hand, when I do my part. Now, I had to shoot 5 or 6 brands of shells to find the one that worked the best in that barrel, but now I am set.

The same should go with your 12 ga. ML. First, measure the bore, to be sure about its exact dimension. Then buy some balls in various diameters, and try different thicknesses of patches, and various lubes, to see what works best. I find that using an overpowder card behind these large round ball seals the bore from gas blow-by, saving both the patching and the round ball from being cut. Then its up to you and your skill as a shooter to make small groups. But most shooters can keep them in a 4 inch circle at 50 yds using a rest, and 8 inches shooting off-hand. That is good enough for deer hunting at those ranges. Remember you are shooting a projectile that is almost 3/4" in diameter, and it carries a tremendous wallop when it hits an animal. It creates a huge primary wound channel that bleeds massively immediately, and is too large to plug up or heal over easily. A deer hit in the chest is going to die fairly quickly.

The work you do in using better sights on your gun, for the light conditions you will be hunting in, and working up an accurate load on the range with your gun reflects your own hunting ethics. There are still guys out there who hunt with a shotgun that has no rear sight, with ammo they buy off the shelf and have never shot at paper to see where it hits, and who would and cripple deer every season before they get lucky to kill one. There are men out there who would not recognize a deer track if it was in neon lights, and make no effort to follow up deer they have shot, if they don't immediately see a Lot of Blood! They don't practice with thei guns between seasons, to keep what shooting skills they have up, nor do they clean their guns from year to year. ( Its only had 3 shots fired through it!) They don't oil or check the gun to make sure its functioning before taking it back out into the field, nor check all the screws to make sure something has not worked loose. They will use ammo that has been rolling around in the back of their pickup truck all year in all kinds of weather, and want to blame the manufacturer if it doesn't fire!

These are the kinds of men who, upon seeing me shoot my slug gun, want to know "Where can I buy a gun like that?" They don't notice the porting at the muzzle, and they can't see the long tapered forcing cone in the barrel that I had done to the factory barrel to make it into the accurate shooter it is. And, they would not understand the importance if they did see it. All they can understand is that the gun is capable of shooting very small groups at 50 yds.
 
Since paul broached modern arms, I'll put in my 2 cents worth. In eastern NC the range is frequently not over 40 yds. so buckshot was the load of choice. I've bagged a number of deer, all with one shot and all dropping in their tracks. I have also hunted with a number of hunters who had frequent misses or wounded deer escaping. The difference, as paul pointed out, is knowing your weapon and practice. I used my grandfather's 12 gauge side by side. Anything except #1 buckshot would really warrant the term scattergun. But with #1 buck the pattern was tight and effective. Taking time to find out what your weapon prefers, be it slug or shot and then practicing, is vital.
bramble
 
Just for stuff and jiggles I shot a few bags of 0.690" balls in my cylinder bore T/C New Englander 12 ga. It throws a credible ball! With practice I am sure 50 yards would be 10" able. I was able to throw some 50 yard three-shot groups all in the 6" bull of my targets. That ain't hay for a little bead front and no rear sight. Having a smoothbore that throws to point of aim is a gift from God, though. I shoot traditional bow and the "instinctive" sighting down a long tube or arrow is kind of ingrained (in spite of the name "instinctive" shooting takes a heck of a lot of practice).
 
A belated thanks for sharing your experiences with 12 gauge projectiles. I immediately ordered up a selection of round balls from Log Cabin and hustled out to the range.

My modern, single-shot percussion piece has a heavy, 29-inch, cylinder bore barrel (.728"), bead front sight, and a shallow, quarter-moon fixture soldered on to the top of the breech block. This fixture serves as a rear sight of sorts.

For a first trial I loaded a .715" RB in front of 80 grains FFg Goex. The wrap is a thin muslin cleaning patch (0.011") into which I pressed a heavy, beeswax-based lubricant using a putty knife.

The first three shots at 50 yards grouped into two inches, just west of the X ring. At 75 yards the group drops about 3-4 inches but stays tight. This combination is stiff to load, so I experimented with a looser-fitting .690" ball patched in heavy pillow ticking, same lube.

For hunting I finally decided to load the larger ball as a first shot in the clean bore, then follow up with a .690" ball ahead of 90 grains FFg in a fouled barrel for the second shot. At 50 yards the latter prints overtop the .715"/80grain combination.

Got out one day in the muzzleloading deer season. No action, but I felt far more confident and better equipped than with buckshot. I appreciate your help.
 
Back
Top