okay, didn't think of the adding iron particles part. That makes a little more sense. I admit to never trying that.
Maybe an odd question, why not use something less destructive for an acid. Ebonizing is done with vinegar and iron particles. You get a very good darkening stain since the same iron is turned into the same very black stain.
That of course is useless if the acids you mentioned are contributing to color changes you wanted.
Is it intentional to get the wood as dark as I often see? (I prefer lighter shades so I can see more of the stripes and color variations)....just wondering.
Sorry if I am hijacking thread, new here and this is something new and interesting.
Chris