L&R tumblers and sears are SOFT. Some time ago they told me what steel they used. 6150 (or is it 5160?...I can never remember. Same thing as their springs). At any rate, I personally don't think they are anywhere near hard enough as they come for wear resistance. On the rare occasion when I use one, I will case harden them with Kasenit, which puts a nice hard skin on them, and then temper them down to brown, like I would if I didn't use the Kasenit (the colors have to be polished off in order to properly see temper colors). I will usually try to temper the half cock hook just a bit more, being careful to not temper down the full cock notch any more. The fly I harden and temper while it's on the tumbler. It's just too dang small for me to do anything with it by itself.
I now do almost everything with Siler parts. Even though I hate O1 steel, I have finally got the hang of fooling with it. It's a decent design, and it makes parts replacement cheap and easy. Plus, I can buy them cheaper!