Was Dutch right about wiping between shots?

[French Colonial]

If I was a ML bench shooter shooting a heavy bench gun................ I might use Dutch's method

But I am not, read olskool and mulebrains posts again, and again until it sinks in, people over complicate things.

 

[nick_1]

I use a lubed patch on my ball. that is all the whiping down that you need, have shot 200 rnds without an extra cleaning. any time you do a cleaning without a load in the chamber you risk a missfire on your next shot. I do shoot percussion though.

 

[Rancocas]

I find 1/16 prone to misfires, I like 5/64 or 3/32
A cavet is that TC used a patent breach and I have heard, not known for myself, that these can have fouling issues

I fully agree with tenngun.
I, too, like a 5/64 or 3/32 touch hole. Also, I have never had a gun with a "patent breech", but I have often heard that people have problems with them. Nor, have I ever had a gun with a vent liner. I agree with Ravenshear that a vent liner was originally a repair for a vent that has so burnt out and enlarged that it needs replacement, which is what a vent liner does.
In our modern times with muzzleloading being recreation or a hobby, wiping between each shot is perfectly okay. However, back in the times when a muzzleloader was the only kind of firearm available, it would be unlikely that people wiped between each shot, especially not military personnel during a battle.
The touch hole should be in the middle of a straight line across the top of the pan. Not down nearer the bottom of the pan. Very little priming powder is needed. Do not fill the pan with priming. Just a bit in the end of the pan away from the touch hole seems to work best, in most cases. You can prime with 4F or you can simply prime with whatever powder you use as your main charge, be it 2F or 3F. Personally, both my load and my prime are the same 3F, and I prime directly from my powder horn, thereby eliminating the need to carry a priming device. But, to each their own on that score.
A vent pick is a handy item. I don't pick between every shot, but I do use it often enough to make sure of a clear passage from the priming to the main charge.
I make my vent picks very easily. A simple paper clip with one end straightened out works just fine for a vent pick. I have also made them by putting a thin nail in the end of a 1/4 or 3/16 dowel, or even just a piece of a stick, cutting off the nail head and filing it to make a slight, dull point. Instead of patches, I keep a vent pick in the patchbox on my rifle.
Good luck in getting your problem solved.

 

[Grenadier1758]

Dutch was fundamentally right.

It is worthwhile to take a look at this cutaway of a T/C breech plug with snail for the nipple seat.

View attachment 243863

We can see the bell shaped chamber and the flash channel that leads to the nipple seat. There is no breech scraper that can clean the flash channel. Fouling can be pushed into the flash channel to impede the ignition path from the nipple seat to the powder chamber. This fouled flash channel may explain @ETipp's one incidence of a hangfire with his T/C New Englander. Because these are hooked breech firearms, the barrel can be removed from the stock and while the breech is immersed in a bucket of water with some soap the barrel can be forcefully flushed to clean the powder chamber and the flash channel. Note that the so called "clean out" screw is pictured too. The factory screw was made of soft steel and unless the utmost of care is taken, that screw slot can be ruined, and the screw can no longer be removed. Eventually T/C changed the manufacturing process to eliminate that plug and that stopped a lot of warranty replacements.

A pipe cleaner can be run from the nipple seat to the powder chamber, but flushing of the barrel is generally sufficient.

The picture is the cut away of a T/C Hawken percussion breech. The flint breech has the nipple breech ground off (or not cast in the first place) and a touch hole liner installed. One can see that a cleaning jag will not enter the chambered breech or the flash channel from the chamber to the touch hole and can push fouling down into the chamber and into the flash channel. A fine flexible brush is needed to keep the flash channel clean.

Since the "never wipe" doesn't push fouling into the chamber, it takes a very long time for the fouling to build up to the point that the flash channel is blocked. Using a very wet patch for the ball actually wipes fouling from the bore above the powder charge. Sinnce the shooting occurs shortly after loading, the moisture from the wet patch doesn't adversely effect the powder charge to the point that accuracy falls off noticeably.

 

[bldtrailer]

I used mutton tallow and can shoot a long time before needing to wipe (I find depending on humidity , the need for wiping can change)

I would like to try Herbs method he loads powder patch and ball then a wet patch on top pushes down the load and pulls the wet patch out with the fouling so every shot is a clean barrel without wetting the breach area

when I wipe at the range I use a cal under bore (45 for50) rides over the fouling 1 wet push down to breach turn to the right ( causing patch to expand ) pulls fouling out instead of pushing into the breach flash hole area use both sides then 2 dry patch and if to very humid a 91%alcohal patch (also used to wipe the rock, pan and frizzen) then pick the flash hole to make sure clear

 

[PathfinderNC]

Every gun is different. I almost never wipe between shots with my rifles- I use spit patch and don’t get stuck balls either.

What works for you might not work for me.

Your job is to discover what works for your rifle.

There are really no shortcuts here, friend.