My whole point! We don't need to be lectured by 45D & told we are all wrong & stupid for shooting & having fun without worrying about the short arbor thing. It's not the end of the world if someone shoots a revolver with a short arbor & no one is going to get killed. Is it a requirement for membership here that you "fix" your short arbor? Why does it matter so much? Can't others also shoot & have fun like you did? Glad you are happy with the work done on your revolvers, but does that mean we all have to follow suit? I am not denying there are short arbors or refuting anything said about them. I'm just saying let people have fun & do what they want to do without trying to make them feel like they must comply to someone else's criteria. To get more people into the hobby it needs to be a bigger tent, not a small tent full of elitists. Think back. If you had read this thread and the comments made by 45D before you bought that Navy, would you have even bothered?
Brother. you are on fire!! Lol!
The op asked a question about what happens when the arbor is short. Zulch gave an honest answer and I followed with an answer. So, the topic IS about the short arbors.
Then you decided "it's overblown " but is an easy fix of a "minor problem ". The op apparently thinks it's serious enough to ask about so, he gets the attention, not you.
You say your example has a correct arbor and wonderful timing right out of the box. I don't doubt that you may think so but I've never seen one new or used that IS correct. So, I doubt your testing method. You didn't respond with any constructive info of how you know yours is correct ( so we all might learn something), but rather you proceeded down the " no big deal" thing so . . .
When I was a heavy casual shooter ( long before I knew anything about what I do today) my Walkers & Dragoons would go through wedges like candy!!! It bothered me but I was having fun ( just like I told French Colonial in post #47 above). Fast forward 25 years and it all made sense. My revolvers shoot smokeless cartridges ( which is much harder on them than bp) and haven't had to replace any wedges at all ( I think there's something to the arbor fit thing!!!).
You ask " what's the big deal?" well, the op asked the question and some of us are trying to help him rather than saying "it's no big deal".
My question directed at French Colonial, again about enlightening us about his correct example. I asked about a pic. He responded with how about me posting a pic of what I was talking about. So, I did.
Thanks to Hawkeye2 for his very kind words.
And . . . all this just because someone smart enough to ask a question about a known manufacturing defect . . . did so and got answers.
Mike