• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Which Custom Cavalry Pistol Would You Choose!?

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Alden

Cannon
Joined
May 23, 2008
Messages
6,476
Reaction score
55
So let's say you were a Congressman and that you were an idiot. But I repeat myself... No, rather let's say you had a choice between two custom made French cavalry pistols.

The first is a large, somewhat fancy, custom made flintlock holster pistol, 20-1/2" long from butt to tip of barrel. The steel barrel is tapered octagon to round with wedding band and is 13-1/2 inches long, in .54 cal smooth bore. The lock is a copy of an Italian design with nice engraving, is made of 4440 steel and the springs and frizzen are 6150 steel. All parts are made by the gunsmith including his own castings. It is a fast lock and has a strong mainspring; it sparks great. The furniture is all brass and it is stocked in American Walnut. The design is based on a very early French Holster Pistol. It's one of a kind.






Now the next is a 1690's era French cavalry pistol from parts by The Rifle Shoppe after an antique pistol. It's stocked in Black Walnut and features a 12" octagon-to-round .50 caliber smoothbore barrel. The barrel, lock, and iron trim are all finished armoury bright. No sights are on this gun either per 17th and early 18th century military fashion where the pistol was designed for use by a mounted troop at close range. Not highly decorated, the stock has simple raised lock panels and a oil finish. The French-style flint lock has a delicate hammer, round-faced lock plate, and no pan bridle in early flintlock fashion. The lock has a smooth action and sparks well.






Which one would you buy?

Now here's the kicker... The second one is 117% more expensive than the first. For example's sake, let's just say that if the first one is $1,000 the second is $2,170.

NOW which one would you buy!?

Yeah, the manly answer is "both" but "neither" is an option you should please keep to yourself...
 
Buy a pair of the fancy .54 pistols and use the rest of your savings to buy powder and flint. :haha:

Many Klatch
 
Pardon me, but "the manly answer" is a brace of 1805 Harper's Ferry pistols.
(NO frog handguns, PLEASE. = CHUCKLE)

yours, satx
USA Military Police Corps, Retired
 
First one but not because it is as flash as a rat with a gold tooth , but because I ;like it's shape and form and style . :)
 
Between the two, the .54. And the display case would be placed beneath the very large shoulder mount(not a horse even though it's French)that I took with it.
 
Well, that's basically the wise-acre "neither" answer I wanted to avoid, but, damnit if you may not be right.

With canvas shoulder holsters?
 
Are you perhaps accusing me of being "a wise-guy"?
(I plead "guilty as charged".- CHUCKLE.)

As you likely know, a crossed brace of the Model 1805 Harper's Ferry pistols is the "branch insignia" of The Military Police Corps.

Today's trivia question: How many Frenchmen does it take to defend Paris?
(I await your answer with bated breath. - LOL.)

yours, satx
 
I love NO. 2. Looks alot like the French Tulle Pattern 1733 pistol. Also, call me a sucker for unadorned pieces of equipment.
 
EXACTLY!!! = CHUCKLE.

ImVho, Eureka Springs, AR is one of the most beautiful places to visit in the USA.
(My late wife & I spent 2 nights of our honeymoon at a B&B there in 1983, which was called: DOGWOODS.)

yours, satx
 
satx78247 said:
Are you perhaps accusing me of being "a wise-guy"?
(I plead "guilty as charged".- CHUCKLE.)

As you likely know, a crossed brace of the Model 1805 Harper's Ferry pistols is the "branch insignia" of The Military Police Corps.

Today's trivia question: How many Frenchmen does it take to defend Paris?
(I await your answer with bated breath. - LOL.)

yours, satx

Not sure exactly. I know it took the combined armies of Russia, Austria, Prussia and Britain 20 years of fighting to find out.
 
Hmm, that's tough. I like #2, I saw it on Track recently and was tempted for a moment (and saw the price!). That makes #1 a real bargain because it's a beauty. Money not being an object, I'd get #2. Money being an object, I'd go for 1 and get another on top of it--like the Pedersoli AN. IX. (The French really did make the best guns)
 
Touche!

Truth is it really hadn't been till the socialist movement took root there that France became the damnable past-glorious nation they are.

And sadly, America is entering the same, if not actually much worse, suicidal death spiral now...
 
Hey the French attacked Greenpeace a few years back and blew one of their ships all to hell if I remember correctly so they haven't lost all of it

All things being equal I like the steel furniture over brass. Brass always looked cheaper to me but I don't know I'd pay 117% more for it
 
Back
Top