Toklo Etee
36 Cl.
- Joined
- Nov 1, 2018
- Messages
- 89
- Reaction score
- 116
A few things that seem to distinguish the Carolina pattern from the NWTG are:I have that Burke article on my hard drive. It's a good one. One thing to note is the difference between what we commonly call Type G/Carolina gun and the later Northwest Trade Gun (NWTG). The former "type" is represented by the extant "Bumford Gun" of which you can see many pictures using an internet search. The original is in the Colonial Williamsburg collection. Though the term "Carolina Gun" continued to be used synonymous with "trade gun" they were not of the same pattern as post-revolutionary war trade guns which we now call NWTGs. In an over generalization, if you are an English-speaking person pre-1780 who happened to own a trade gun or if you are a member of an Indian tribe who trades with the English (and you don't own a Wilson-made trade rifle), then the gun you have most likely resembles the Bumford gun... perhaps not with the painted vines, maybe not painted blue or red, but definitely in that general form with brass hardware. I'm not as familiar with the NWTGs, and I'm not familiar with their use outside of the geographic location that their name entails.
Butt stock architecture- they both had the plate nailed on but the Carolina gun butt plate was more ornate with some floral engraving. It seems the comb of the NWTG was very straight in relation to the barrel. Carolina guns tended to have a little more drop(had a chance to examine an original butt plate back in November....very thin brass)
Stock treatment- I am not aware of any NWTG that were listed as being 'painted" The Carolina guns were primarily stocked in beech. There are descriptions of the stocks being painted Blue, red, Yellow & "spotted" I wonder if the Bumford fell in that category?
Side plates- the typical Carolina serpent side plate was engraved flat brass that was inletted into the stock....The latter NWTG side plates were still serpents but cast with more 3 D details
Barrel- The extant Bumford & TR gun have 46 inch barrels. One detail particular to the Carolina guns is the brass rear sight. I have not had the opportunity to look at any original NWTG....The pictures I've seen seem to be devoid of a factory rear sight. I have often thought the rear sight was an indicator that these guns were being used primarily like deer hunting slug guns with the ability to use shot for small game.
As I stated before....if the builder uses a correct barrel profile.....these things are light. At 5 1/2# it is an easy gun to carry around. When you compare the assault weapon of the time...1st model Brown Bess.....the Carolina guns weight almost half. In Alabama the Carolina gun parts are scattered everywhere....I've seen found parts form north, south east & west..... looking at the map Mr. Burke included in his article.....these things must have been imported in astronomical numbers & then used into Oblivion
I can truly say I do not regret the kidney I had to sell to buy mine built by the late Dave Wagner.....it is a great shooter!
David