Your favourite/best trophy

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
NOPE, I cannot replace my FIRST "really BIG game" trophy OR "just forget it", any more than I can forget my first serious kiss by a certain XYL, especially considering that it SUPPOSEDLY was "unavoidably lost over the side"."
I later asked a friend (An MPI, who worked the port area) if this was a commonplace thing & he said, "I know of ONE other instance of that sort of thing. - The loss of a container that held a COL's gun collection."
("Passing odd" don't you think, especially since the ACO paid me, despite my NOT having made a claim against the government?? = 400.oo was a considerable sum in 1971.)

As I said, I suspect (but do NOT know) that someone HAS my Hirsch trophy. = !@#$%^&!

Let me tell you just a bit about that long-ago morning:
(SORRY, I don't write like Hemingway, Ruark, Capstick or any other hunting author. - I am just going to try to tell you how that morning seems, after 4 decades.)

The Senior Forstmeister & I walked 2-3 KM to a tree with the tree-stand about 10-15M up in the tree, about an hour or so before sun-up, on the morning of the 6th day of my 10-day leave.
We silently climbed up to the stand and settled ourselves comfortably among the branches.
About 10 minutes later, the night-moving animals began making noises again & soon some birds began chattering. Then I heard a squirrel barking close by, though it was still too dark to see him.

As dawn began to break, I heard "some movement in the woods" but even with my 7x50 binoculars, I could see nothing clearly. A few minutes later (which seemed like HOURS), the ground-fog lifted & I could see a young Hirsh & his mother grazing quietly about 20M away.
(The forstmeister, shook his head & silently touched my arm and motioned to the other side of the clearing that we were sitting above. - I could see NOTHING but thick brush & trees in that direction.)

After what seemed like hours, suddenly a huge Hirsch soundlessly appeared as if BY MAGIC (He was JUST THERE!) in the edge of the woods, right where the forstmeister had pointed, about 70-80M away.
(Through my glass, he looked as big as a house.)
He was standing behind some bushes and I clearly remember thinking three separate/distinct things:
1. "PLEASE, PLEASE God, let him walk out from behind that stuff. I do NOT want to shoot into that mess.",
2, "He's BEAUTIFUL"
and
3. "Don't let me screw this up."
(Germans generally think that Americans cannot hunt competently or even shoot well and they don't mostly bother to hide their disdain for NON-European hunters. = I strongly suspect, that if it wasn't for the SOFA, that NO Americans would be licensed in FRG.)

Suddenly, he stepped out into the clearing & after a quick look through his binoculars, the forstmeister mouthed, "SHOOT, SHOOT" (in German).

I have NO memory whatever of seeing the Hirsch in my scope, squeezing the trigger, of the recoil or even the crack of my rifle.
Suddenly, the Hirsh just collapsed, kicked his hind legs a few times & then lay still. I ejected the empty case & worked the action in case I needed to fire again.
(The forstmeister signaled me NOT to fire again. - "TODT" was all he said.)

We sat quietly for a couple of minutes.
Then we climbed down the tree, gave him "the last bite, my face was smeared with his blood, he shook my hand & then we began the field dressing procedure.

FULL DISCLOSURE: Despite the forstmeister's OK, my Hirsh really wasn't a "II-B". - Instead, he was a "I-B" or perhaps verging into being a "II-A".
I now believe that Mr. Brauer "took pity on the kid", as we had seen NO shootable trophies. We had seen MANY does, fawns, "culls" and even a "I-A Kapitol", (which NO American would ever be allowed to collect,) but NO "II-B" game. - When we got back to the Forstampt, the other forest department personnel "looked askance" at my guide, as if he might have "suddenly gone blind".

Note: The taxidermist at WAFFEN BENNEWITZ congratulated me on such a "great-looking trophy", which was supposed to be a "II-B".
(He wasn't fooled either.)

That's a BITTER-SWEET memory of "my mis-spent youth". = NO trophy can replace that one!

yours, satx
 
Mine was a little 4-point (and 'little' describes a lot of whitetail in central Texas) I took with a .58 pistol carbine. It was one of those Navy Arms M.1855 Dragoon pistols with a shoulder stock I never used for hunting. The smaller Minie was one of those with the semi-wadcutter look and it knocked him into the nickle bleachers. What there was in horn got made into knife handles and buttons. The buttons were a waste, didn't know how soft antler hearts were. All I've got now are memories of a fun hunt and the taste of smothered venison steaks over home made noodles! Believe I'm content with that!

Last season's "Ode To A Daft Squirrel" adventure will probably be my all-time favorite hunting memory, but that one still stands out as a one-of-a-kind deer memory! :thumbsup: The M.1855 is a memory too but I did smoke up the Astrodome with it a few years later! Another good story! :wink:
 
I made my osage bow and arrows, found a pinch point in a hardwood hollow and set up a ground blind made of beech limbs with the leaves on and had this guy walk through my trap, shot him a 7 yards. Public hunting area, off the ground with homemade equipment, I won't ever top this one.



Here is my makeshift blind;

 
Eric, what a beautiful photo! You can't beat a close encounter on the ground with a truly primitive weapon!

My all-time favorite is a longbow-shot small 7-point from 7 steps that was the most exciting sit I've ever experienced. In my post above I listed my muzzleloading best experience, but for excitement and primitive hunting, this guy was the tops.
 
Your set-up is a mirror of mine, Eric, including the little folding chair. That's the perfect elevation; a tree is too high, the ground is too low; a folding seat is perfect.
 
That blind looks way too comfy. That beauty would have walked on by me while I was sleeping!😊

primitive bow and a ground blind is the true essence of hunting. Very rare these days😞
 
The hollow is about 200 yards long, full big white oak trees. The land 50 yards above the bottom of the hollow is planted in 15 year old pines, thick as hair on a dogs back.

Before I shot this deer I had hunted the hollow a few times and saw deer every time I was there. I have been back at least a dozen times to my bind over the years and never seen another deer, pretty strange.
 
When I killed my first "whitetail" w/ a MLer, I thought it was possibly a "trophy" and that lasted for a spell and then along came an elk kill w/ the same MLer and that then was possibly thought of as a "trophy". Don't exactly know what defines a kill as a "trophy" seeing I'm mainly a meat hunter. Never took any pics of any kills.....that's not exactly true. Once took a pic of the family eating my venison stew. :grin: ....Fred
 
My favorite deer trophy is this one I got with my ML a long time ago.

RONSDEER97.jpg


My favorite Antelope is this one

9-25-10Lsmall.jpg


AntelopefinishedAsmall.jpg


Ron
 
I am like you Fred, a meat hunter. I mounted the first big buck I killed when I was in my 20s. This was in the sawdust and paper mache deer form era, it only slightly resembles a deer today.

I have the memories, I feel no need to mount anything and I save a few hundred bucks in the process. I do take pictures though, but only in a way that shows respect for the deer now days. No gut pile, entry wound, strung up on meat pole pictures.

I messed up on the deer in the picture. It was huge for this area so I thought it would be tough and gamey. I donated all the deer less the backstraps to Hunters Feeding the Hungry. When I cooked up the backstraps I found them to be fork tender and as good as any deer I have ever eaten, I guessed wrong.
 
That is a nice mount of the antelope ant the mulie is huge. This isn't a thread for meat hunters...
 
My favorite "trophies" were all of my "firsts"... my first deer ever (a doe taken with a compound bow at age 45); my first fox (with a bow), my first raccoon (with a bow); my first buck (taken with a modern rifle (a nice Bradford Co., PA 8-point); my first flintlock buck; and my first deer taken with a longbow.

That first flintlock buck was barely legal in PA... 3 points on one side. And that's exactly what he had... only one antler with three points! Not a real looker... but he'll always be a trophy to me! My son now has a knife made (by Rich McDonald) from that antler!

RMantlerknife001.jpg


RMantlerknife003.jpg


Now that I live in Colorado, I still can look forward to my first mulie, my first pronghorn and my first elk! :grin:
 
Back
Top