Who Hunts Reg Seasons With Their Muzzleloader?

Thingamajiggy · Sep 19, 2024

My goal over the last several years is to be flintlock only but I gotta put meat in the freezer. So between work and hunting success, will honestly say it hasn't always worked out that way. I do hunt our muzzleloader seasons with Flintlock only though.

Daveboone · Sep 19, 2024

More so over the past few years, but not exclusively. I have a couple stands where max 50 yard shots present, but if I am in one of my stands with expected longer shots likely my unmentionable. Or...if it is just too wet. I love to hunt the slop.

flatcreek · Sep 19, 2024

Years ago in NJ you could only use buckshot. I started hunting with muzzleloader around then when they started allowing it and have always hunted deer with a muzzleloader in all seasons it was allowed.

Cliffdweller · Sep 19, 2024

Yanqui said:
Just curious who hunts traditional during the “regular”season and thoughts? I have for many years and can’t say I’ve felt handi-capped. I do tend to hunt quite remote areas where I rarely see anyone. Not sure how I’d feel about it with heavy hunting pressure? I’ll say I could care less if I actually do succeed at this point in life, but, I do hunt hard and am not shy to shoot if opportunity presents itself. All in all it’s a great feeling to be out in the boonies with one good shot at the ready and that sweet looking piece of WOOD on my lap. Thoughts or comments?

You said it all right there, totally agree

kelljp · Sep 19, 2024

Our muzzleloader season transsitons to modern firearms in November. Since 2010 I found it easier to continue hunting the remaining deer season with my muzzleloader.
Probably it started out as being too busy/ lazy to get my modern rifle zeroed in before season, but later it was a challenge ( that my hunting buddies rode me about). What I found was it made me slow down and try for closer,better shots. My success numbers actually increased and tagging out wasn't uncommon.

Loyalist Dave · Sep 19, 2024

Yanqui said:
Just curious who hunts traditional during the “regular”season and thoughts? I have for many years and can’t say I’ve felt handi-capped. I do tend to hunt quite remote areas where I rarely see anyone. Not sure how I’d feel about it with heavy hunting pressure? I’ll say I could care less if I actually do succeed at this point in life, but, I do hunt hard and am not shy to shoot if opportunity presents itself. All in all it’s a great feeling to be out in the boonies with one good shot at the ready and that sweet looking piece of WOOD on my lap. Thoughts or comments?

What is this "regular season" of which you speak? For me deer is "open" or it's not. My .54 Cabin Creek brand rifle has put more venison on my table than most of my friends with their new fangled "all weather" rifles.

LD

Cliffdweller · Sep 19, 2024

Loyalist Dave said:
What is this "regular season" of which you speak? For me deer is "open" or it's not. My .54 Cabin Creek brand rifle has put more venison on my table than most of my friends with their new fangled "all weather" rifles.

LD

Boomerang · Sep 19, 2024

Ya I didn't know that there was an irregular deer season.

Kev308 · Sep 19, 2024

Although I have the pre-requisite 30-06 with a 3X9 scope, for hunting in Pa. I really much prefer taking my smoothbore flint with me anytime I go out. There’s just something unique about taking a flintlock out under the trees.

19112tap · Sep 19, 2024

I primarily used a traditional ML from 1986 to 2000 When I lived in a State that was a shotgun or ML for deer season then I moved to a State that allowed the use of unmentionable's but I still used ML during the special ML season. In the last few years I have been going back to ML and have been using a flintlock. As I have several unmentionable's I for see myself using them again but my hunting location is very dense and shot's are close so it's ideal for ML hunting.

Ditt44 · Sep 19, 2024

Kev308 said:
Although I have the pre-requisite 30-06 with a 3X9 scope, for hunting in Pa. I really much prefer taking my smoothbore flint with me anytime I go out. There’s just something unique about taking a flintlock out under the trees.

I think there is a deeper connection with a flintlock, much like hunting squirrels with a small-bore .32 cap lock. I think you find yourself listening more, being slower, paying more attention when you hunt with a 'lesser' weapon that can't lay a bullet into a quarter at 200 yards. You know you need to be more aware, stealthy and get closer. I liken it to hunting squirrels, I have always been told from my grandfather to my dad that if you can be a good squirrel hunter, you can be a decent deer hunter. I believe that applies to flint to center fire as well. If you can master one, it will make you that much better at the other. They should be complimentary skills, not adversaries.

Yanqui · Sep 19, 2024

Have really enjoyed reading all the replies! I too have hunted many years with a traditional bow, really loving that sweet lightness in my hand. And I love too the alchemy of that witches brew of basic black and lead. I realized many years ago I don’t eat all that much meat so I’m making g it as much a challenge as I can. There’s just a beauty to the equipment that can’t be denied.

rkg1 · Sep 19, 2024

I do sometimes. It depends on where I will be and how far the shots will be

Gum Slough Muzzleloader · Sep 19, 2024

brazosland said:
Did you offer to give him 10 seconds to run before you started shooting with your fake gun?

That's a good one.

Gum Slough Muzzleloader · Sep 19, 2024

Nobody85 said:
I do all my hunting with either my 16 bore fowler, or 50. Where I live, there’s no reason to use modern weapons as it’s impossible to see more than 100 yards in any direction. I’ve been packing the freezer for years that way and have never felt disadvantaged in any way. I have plenty of modern weapons and don’t hold it against someone who uses them to take game. I just prefer they way our ancestors got things done.

Well said

Thunder Bay · Sep 19, 2024

Yes, I do. I’ll be out again this November with my GPR hoping to see a big ol northern Minnesota buck. Most places I hunt I see more Moose and Wolf sign than deer but what the heck it’s fun to out there with a BP gun.

Gum Slough Muzzleloader · Sep 19, 2024

I hunt the General Gun Season , Turkey season, and squirrel with muzzleloaders. This will be the first year that I'll be using PRBs for deer and hog. I be using flintlock and percussion.

Take Care Stay Safe

Jay Templin · Sep 19, 2024

I pretty much only hunt deer with my muzzleloaders. Well, and I just started bowhunting on Tuesday.

One of the main reasons we bought a house and land in Charles City was that it was a rifle county. Until the year after we moved in.

We can use unmentionables up to and including .50 BMG for WOODCHUCKS, but no modern rifles at all for deer.
Jay

Yanqui · Sep 19, 2024

Thunder Bay said:
Yes, I do. I’ll be out again this November with my GPR hoping to see a big ol northern Minnesota buck. Most places I hunt I see more Moose and Wolf sign than deer but what the heck it’s fun to out there with a BP gun.

Good luck! A tip of the hat to you..

Eddie Southgate · Sep 20, 2024

I hunt till I kill what I want with which ever modern gun I'm using then usually finish the season with one of the muzzleloaders. We have a short muzzleloading season and a long gun season in Alabama. Gun season runs from about the 18th or so of November till February 10th . Muzzleloading season is the two weeks before gun season. I do kill coyotes and armadillos year round with both muzzleloaders and cartridge guns.

Who Hunts Reg Seasons With Their Muzzleloader?

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

54 Cal.

45 Cal.

40 Cal

40 Cal

69 Cal.

Cannon

40 Cal

.54 Cal.

40 Cal

36 Cl.

40 Cal

I hate change! It’s never the same! Archie Bunker

40 Cal

45 Cal.

45 Cal.

36 Cl.

45 Cal.

45 Cal.

I hate change! It’s never the same! Archie Bunker

36 Cal.

Similar threads

Join the conversation!

Join today and get all the highlights of this community direct to your inbox. It's FREE!