• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Finishing a walnut stock...

shop deals on amazon
Shop deals on ebay
Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Bedford County Doc

Bedford County Doc

40 Cal
MLF Supporter
Joined
Mar 16, 2024
Messages
102
Reaction score
98
I'm using a mixture of 1/3 turpentine, 1/3 tried-and-true, and 1/3 Marine Spar varnish to finish my Kibler Colonial stock. I applied five coats of this mixture. The last coat was still sticky after four days, so I tried gently heating it with a hair dryer without much success. So, I tried rubbing the finish down with just a hint of turpentine, which seemed to dry everything up. What do I do next? Add a couple of CCs of turpentine to my 1/3, 1/3, 1/3 mixture and rub it in again? Shift to a commercial mixture of beeswax and orange oil? Or maybe use Permalyn as a top coat? Most of the pores seem to be filled in because I used a dowel to vigorously burnish the wood prior to trying to finish it?

Thanks very much for your kind thoughts!
//Doc
 
Bedford County Doc said:
I'm using a mixture of 1/3 turpentine, 1/3 tried-and-true, and 1/3 Marine Spar varnish to finish my Kibler Colonial stock. I applied five coats of this mixture. The last coat was still sticky after four days, so I tried gently heating it with a hair dryer without much success. So, I tried rubbing the finish down with just a hint of turpentine, which seemed to dry everything up. What do I do next? Add a couple of CCs of turpentine to my 1/3, 1/3, 1/3 mixture and rub it in again? Shift to a commercial mixture of beeswax and orange oil? Or maybe use Permalyn as a top coat? Most of the pores seem to be filled in because I used a dowel to vigorously burnish the wood prior to trying to finish it?

Thanks very much for your kind thoughts!
//Doc
Click to expand...
Don't know about that mixture, but I would not put any more coats of finish untill you cure up the sticky.
I use polymerized tung oil. No muss no fuss.
Good luck
Larry
 
The sticky stuff went away after I rubbed it down with a piece of cloth faintly damp with turpentine. That was 24 hours ago, and the stock feels smooth to the touch now.
 
I just completed a TC Hawken stock refinish using your described finish (1-1-1). I ran into a similar situation with my 3 or 4th coat. I added just a touch more turpentine for the final coat. It helped with curing time. I don’t think you need to do anything for a final coat. I let mine set for about a week or 10 days and didn’t mess with it. Finish is fully cured. Here’s a picture
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2903.jpeg
    IMG_2903.jpeg
    499.8 KB
  • IMG_2870.jpeg
    IMG_2870.jpeg
    699.8 KB
  • IMG_2871.jpeg
    IMG_2871.jpeg
    746.2 KB
It sounds like you are applying too much finish at one time. Thick coats of finish don't polymerize well; that's why it feels sticky.

Dip in a finger tip, put a couple of drops on the stock, rub it into a 3-4 inch square area with the heel of your hand until you feel some heat, then do another 3-4 inches. Set it down for few days until as Crisco Kid says you can't smell it. Then repeat the process.

It will take some time, but repeated hand rubbed thin coats will get you what you want.
 
rchas said:
It sounds like you are applying too much finish at one time. Thick coats of finish don't polymerize well; that's why it feels sticky.

Dip in a finger tip, put a couple of drops on the stock, rub it into a 3-4 inch square area with the heel of your hand until you feel some heat, then do another 3-4 inches. Set it down for few days until as Crisco Kid says you can't smell it. Then repeat the process.

It will take some time, but repeated hand rubbed thin coats will get you what you want.
Click to expand...
Just had the same issue with Tru-Oil on a fairly nice supposedly walnut stock. 3rd coat took over a week to cure up enough to handle. 4th coat was applied, rubbed in and ready for a 5th coat within 4-5 hours. Same bottle for the last 3 coats. Dark amber versus the usual clear. No dyes or thinners, just straight out of the several years old bottle.
Only difference was a tropical depression came through 2 days after coat 3, and dropped close to 7” of rain in 72 hours.
Stock in question, IF walnut, is black walnut sapwood, or lower end thin shell (English). Instantly oxidized to light ochre when air hit fresh scraping/sanding. Nice random curl in a couple spots, and some mineral lines. Older (late 1940s) USA built.
 
I have used a lot of Tru-oil on bows, arrows and guns, it does have a shelf life and doesn't dry right if it has been stored for several years.

Every now and then I buy a bad new bottle right off the shelf that remains tacky forever. I like to buy my Tru-oil at Walmart because they sell more of it and the bottles are fresher.
 
rchas said:
Very true. Once opened, I turn the bottle cap down to store it. That seems to help but its not worth keeping after a year or so.
Click to expand...
The old bottle, other than going amber, works fine on small projects. IF the humidity is stable. Will likely cut it with Starbrite Premium Golden Teak Oil and a bit of thinner as a good soak in oil for base coats. I like lighter colored stocks.
 
Following ... ... Very interesting . I love my trade guns and the traditional finish on them was varnish , as listed many many times by the HBCo ... It dries fast and protects the wood unlike &%#@ oil finishes ... I dislike oil very much . BUT ....to find an authentic varnish , at least in my neck of the woods isnt easy ...everything is poly . No way I'm using that unauthentic garbage on my trade guns . Any who ...best of luck .I like the authentic finishes and techniques...
 
Rob M. said:
Following ... ... Very interesting . I love my trade guns and the traditional finish on them was varnish , as listed many many times by the HBCo ... It dries fast and protects the wood unlike &%#@ oil finishes ... I dislike oil very much . BUT ....to find an authentic varnish , at least in my neck of the woods isnt easy ...everything is poly . No way I'm using that unauthentic garbage on my trade guns . Any who ...best of luck .I like the authentic finishes and techniques...
Click to expand...
Seal/fill the grain with a shellac spit coat and top with a linseed oil varnish. Tried and True is a good commercially made choice.
 
Tried and True on Amazon is $35 a pint. If I buy a whole pint there will be enough left over to varnish my coffin. I tried hot water bath canning some poly in 4 oz. jelly jars and it seemed to be as good as new after 4 or 5 years. I don't know if it would work for other types of finish.
 
Doc,

Any finish I have ever used (and I have tried a lot of them) has ALWAYS dried better in the sun. The UV in sunlight rapidly kicks over the cross linking required to get most finishes to dry completely. I actually use what I call a "stock rotisserie". I like to dry stains and finishes in the warm California sun, but I get tired of running back and forth to flip the stock over and around. Call me lazy, but I had a small 1 RPM synchronous motor, left over from some other project or other, and some scrap plywood and made up this "stock rotisserie". I can move it around as needed and hang it on a hook or clamp it to something and it twirls the stock around in the sun for me once a minute.





 

Similar threads

Buff1958
New Cherry burl stock
2
Replies
27
Views
1K
Buff1958
Buff1958
S
Walnut finish problem
2
Replies
23
Views
908
Sledgehammers_at_Dawn
S
TDM
.36 cal SMR in Walnut completed
2 3 4
Replies
72
Views
4K
Gordoncourtney
G
A
Modifying Chambers Traditional Oil Finish to slow drying
2
Replies
22
Views
1K
Antelope Pete
A
L
Need some advise on my finished stock
Replies
9
Views
627
wiscoaster
wiscoaster

Latest posts

Back
Top