• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

2012 Hunting Accident Report

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Loyalist Dave

Cannon
Staff member
Moderator
MLF Supporter
Joined
Nov 22, 2011
Messages
17,047
Reaction score
16,004
Location
People's Republic of Maryland
I just got a copy of the Maryland 2012 hunting accident report.

No fatalities. Out of twenty-four events, Sixteen of the events involved falling out of tree stands. (WHICH is why Loyalist Dave don't get into no tree stand. :wink: )

Two events were with bows, one guy shot himself in his foot, one fellow got cut by a broadhead.

Five involved modern guns, one fellow shot himself, two fellows shot other hunters, a landowner was hit by shot pellets, and a home was struck with a rifle round (the last two may not have been "hunters").

Only one event in twenty-four involved a muzzleloader.

A 19 year old Cecil County [Maryland] deer hunter shot himself in the left foot. Upon investigation it was determined the victim was in the act of recovering wounded game; he had stopped to rest, and placed the muzzle of a .50 caliber muzzleloader on his left foot, the gun discharged causing a self-inflicted injury to the left foot. The victim stated he did not know how the gun went off. The victim suffered a wound to the left toe.

The report does not say if this was an inline or a traditional arm. My wild arsed guess is that he didn't wait, but quickly reloaded, and went after the deer. He saw the game move off, he cocked his rifle, and kept after it, trying to jump shoot it, got tired and careless, and now we can call him Gimpy.


So for 2012, the safest hunters in Maryland are those using muzzleloaders and regular or compound bows.

LD
 
I wonder how many of the 16 that fell out of stands were alcohol related? I stopped hunting conventional season when I lived in Minnesota because there were too many guys that thought hunting meant drinking and shooting up the woods. Muzzleloader season seemed to weed out the rif-raf.
 
Even smart people do dumb things,all and all sharp objects weeds out the stupid.I never understood the treestand thing.and Dave I'll be on the ground with you
 
I don't do tree stands either. :thumbsup: Espesialy those climbing ones :surrender: I'm clumsy enough just walking in the woods. :surrender:
 
Yeah I agree, I can injure myself without any problems when walking through the woods, or handling sharp knives, not to mention having a sharp flint mounted in a lock. Heck last fall I simply got out of bed one morning and thought I had impaled my foot on a piece of broken glass though how the glass got there I couldn't begin to guess, and there was no blood... (turns out it was Plantar Faciitis :( Sure felt like I'd been stabbed! )

I don't need to tempt fate by going aloft. :nono:

LD
 
Loyalist Dave said:
So for 2012, the safest hunters in Maryland are those using muzzleloaders and regular or compound bows.
Total numbers only tell part of the story. What percentage of accidents occurred, based on the type of weapon would also be helpful.

Example: If you have thousands in Group A and only hundreds in Group B, we might expect the total number of incidents to be fewer in Group B.
 
Well IF you want to actually be accurate in your conversation I suppose that would apply. :grin:

I mean you're right if there were only 10 muzzleloader hunters in the state, then that one ML accident means 10% of the muzzleloader hunters got injured, and if there are 16 folks with modern guns falling out of tree stands but there were 1600 modern gun hunters out last year, and the same 1600 modern gun using hunters also used tree stands, then only 1% of them got injured.... :shocked2:

They have no idea how many folks went hunting, as landowners don't need licenses, and how many folks got hurt falling out of stands or cut by a broadhead screwing it on, but didn't go to the hospital/doctor so it wasn't reported, and then out of the number of licenses sold, how many of those folks actually went hunting, and then add to that how many folks went once vs. how many folks spent several days out hunting..., I mean just 'cause you didn't fall out of your stand the one time you went out doesn't mean you were "safe" when doing so, right? Plus if you spend more time in the woods, odds are you have a better chance of a mishap while in the woods, no?

Note something else..., ALL of the incidents save for the lady hit by birdshot (which might not have been a hunter) were all deer hunting incidents in 2012. In the past we have had folks having accidents when turkey hunting, upland bird hunting, and squirrel hunting. Not last year though..., as far as we know.

LD
 
tree stands in norther MN increase your range, and abilities to see game when they're placed in wooded areas. Instead of being able to see 30 yards, you can now see 60, which roughly quadruples your shooting area. The down side is that you're pretty stuck in that spot for awhile, and it's one more thing to lug in and out of the woods, and takes some tome to set up and take down. And of course adds the element of falling out as an additional risk.
 
always cracks me up when i see "i dont know how the gun went off" it went off because you pulled the trigger moron. yeah i know everyonce in a bluemoon a mechanical malfunction will cause a gun to fire but we all know most of these people who the gun somehow goes off on pulled the trigger while the muzzle was pointed in an unsafe direction. they jusy dont want to admit it.
 
One of the non-muzzleloader reports (which I didn't provide as it's not proper for our forum) the guy's rifle went off, accidentally, four times. :shocked2: In another the guy's shotgun went off he thinks because a branch or twig hit the trigger (and I suppose the same branch also flipped off the safety?). Then there was the guy who shot his friend at 60 yards with 00 buck, while doing a deer drive and not wearing blaze orange..., aka poaching as buckshot is a no-no in this state. :nono:

I only mention these brief details for us traditional muzzleloading hunters as many of us, including myself, hunt with the traditional rifles and guns in regular gun season..., so be forewarned ..., the goofballs are out there, and they are armed!

LD
 
Just a few years ago while I still lived in Ga, there was a freak hunting fatality indirectly involving a tree stand. Near my home a man was hunting with his son and, IIRC, a nephew. He was in a tree stand and when noontime arrived they decided to break for lunch. As this gentleman finished climbing down from the stand, he put his foot too close to one of our big canebreak rattlers. 911 was called but the hunter was dead by the time they got him out of the woods - the EMTs said it took only 15 minutes from bite to fatality.
 
holy mackeral hanshi posting something like that might keep me in the house til thanksgiving.
 
My foot is killing me just thinking about a 50 going thru it not to mention the powder burns. Ouch! Geo. T.
 
One year I took some kin of my wife (niece's husband & his brothers) up and set them in a camp on the Grand mesa.

Three days later I get a call to pick him up from the ER! He had fallen & had to be helicoptered out :shocked2: I go into St. Mary's ER, which was full of sprains & brakes, mostly hunters, and as he limps out on a crutch, I said loudly "Holly cow! Rich, I put you on the biggest flat-topped mountain IN THE WORLD, and you still managed to fall off the side! :doh: " The whole ER started laughing at him :grin: He didn't say a word to me the rest of the day.
 
I have cut my hand bad and needed 8 stiches when I found someone else's broadhead inside a deer while field dressing it.
 
The shooting oneself in the foot is a fairly common event. Ask any ER employee. I once had an opportunity to ask an old timer who had done this to himself how it happened. He said he put the muzzle of his (modern lever type)gun on the top of his foot and pulled the trigger to see of the gun was loaded. :confused: :youcrazy: He was about 70 years old and had been doing this routine since he started hunting as a youngster. Asking others, I have determined that it is a common practice. :doh: Yep. I don't understand it either. Just plain nutso :youcrazy: IMHO.
 
Rifleman1776 said:
The shooting oneself in the foot is a fairly common event. He said he put the muzzle of his (modern lever type)gun on the top of his foot and pulled the trigger to see of the gun was loaded. Asking others, I have determined that it is a common practice. :doh: Yep. I don't understand it either. Just plain nutso :youcrazy: IMHO.

Wonderful now when I limp in a new hunting camp, I'll have to explain that it's not a shot foot & sign of a low I.Q. :nono: , it's just a bad knee. :rotf:
 
Back
Top