• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

.45 caliber RB enough for deer?

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
No.

The animal deserves a quick, clean kill.

I hunt with a 2-bore bronze swivel gun that I strap to the tree with ratchet straps. My usual hunting load is a 3,500 grain lead ball with 800 grains of 1Fg black powder.

;)

I'm sure you sight your target before firing. I can't because I use an old Civil War era light mortar and have to rely on the rule of 'closeys count".
 
90 caliber Stoeger Arms
20210804_150130.jpg
 
Iv killed a lot of deer. Its all about shot placement not size of lead size. I seen where folks have killed deer with small rimfire im not saying. I would do that 36 cal 40 cal 45 cal 50 cal 54 ,58 62, they all will kill a deer If you can take out a deer heart with a well place shot it will die
 
Iv killed a lot of deer. Its all about shot placement not size of lead size. I seen where folks have killed deer with small rimfire im not saying. I would do that 36 cal 40 cal 45 cal 50 cal 54 ,58 62, they all will kill a deer If you can take out a deer heart with a well place shot it will die
Absolutely…lots of people here seem to compare the performance of their muzzleloaders to modern smokeless firearms. I read these posts about velocity and energy when hunting…

I see more similarity between a muzzleloader and a bow & arrow, than I do between a muzzleloader and a modern centerfire.

Shot placement.…it’s what matters most.
 
Both of your animals are mighty fine. The buck is amazing, I love a big typical frame buck, hands down.

But that doe is big, WOW, nice mature doe…how much did she weigh? Curious minds want know…was she alone or in a group? Was she leading the group, or bringing up the rear?

I want to hear details….
 
Both of your animals are mighty fine. The buck is amazing, I love a big typical frame buck, hands down.

But that doe is big, WOW, nice mature doe…how much did she weigh? Curious minds want know…was she alone or in a group? Was she leading the group, or bringing up the rear?

I want to hear details….

She was alone, last light, opening weekend of the general season. Spotted her at over 300yds. Put in a fast efficient stalk to get to these scrubby trees, ranged her at 57 yards feeding and I squeezed off the shot, gave her a healthy double lung. Tucked myself back into the trees, reloaded and went out and my buddy pointed me to where she went. Found her in the next set of bushy trees. No clue what she weighed but it took both my buddy and I to get her on the quad and tied down. I got 48lb of burger from her after adding 15% beef fat to the meat. Very healthy doe.
 
The .45 calibre is great for antelope and deer sized game.

A good place to start when developing a PRB load is around 45-50 grains of powder. From my experience the .45 is one of those calibers that works well for either fffg or ffg…though most of my shooting is done with fffg. Lots of people here will disagree on using ffg in a .45 calibre, to each his own.

PRB loads for hunting usually fall into the 55 grain to 70 grain range. My personal .45 calibre muzzleloaders fall into 55 to 60 grains for hunting loads. You'll not need to use big powder charges in the .45 calibre.

Conical bullets, maxi balls etc. usually shoot best with a twist rate of 48” or faster…though I've seen enough PRB barrels shoot conicals just fine, so hit or miss. Loads for conical are going to be in the 55 grain to 75 grain range. Most of my .45’s these days are PRB guns, though I still have one rifle that is just so accurate with conicals. It likes a load of 65 grains of fffg.

Regardless of your projectile type, you'll want a load that is accurate out to at least 100yrds, even if you limit your shooting to much closer shooting situations. I've taken maybe one deer at or maybe just beyond 100yrds, while the vast majority of my deer, taken with a muzzleloader, have been between 20yrds and 60yrds.

As a good published resource…Lyman had a Blackpowder loading book, that was fairly comprehensive. If you can find a copy of that publication, it would be to your benefit.

https://www.amazon.com/Powder-Handb...1&s=books&sprefix=Lyman,stripbooks,175&sr=1-2
fainter. Prefer a .50 or larger for hunting, but have taken deer with a .45.
 
fainter. Prefer a .50 or larger for hunting, but have taken deer with a .45.
The .50 is an awesome calibre. My prime rifle for 25-30 years was a .50 calibre CVA Mountain Rifle…got it at 13 and hunted everything from prairie dogs, to squirrels & rabbits, to deer, Elk, & antelope. Then I started branching out and exploring…different calibres, smoothbores, various handgun profiles…wow it’s awesome. I love this sport/hobby.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top