Ok, so I have had these problems as well with caps and buggered up nipples. Got mine to fit when I got an assortment and just dry fitted some caps on them at the dinner table one night and sorted them out with various caps. Marked the caps in a left over cap tin. However, maybe its from fear from the old days, but pushing down on the cap? I guess I don't do that since I had some firecrackers and the red caps go off in my fingers when I was young. Just doesn't seem the right thing to do I guess. On the line pushing the cap onto the nipple, just not a pretty picture for me...I realize we are not talking here putting 200 plus pounds of force on it, but just see those little red caps going off in the old days with a little cap gun gives me the hebbee jeebees...