I am still in favor of leaving the knot as is, though the shellac method in the Potterfield is easy enough and looks good, at least for while in my experience (I’ve seen such shellac repairs develop checking in them over time).
Just as an example of factory knothole from over 50 years ago, here is a photograph of a Winchester 94 I purchased new while in high school with a fairly large repair, though I’m not sure what the repair material was, the old man called it plastic and I got the gun with a discount and a few boxes of shells tossed in.
For what it is worth, the bluing is about worn off the gun, but ‘patch’ in the stock is still holding.
Just as an example of factory knothole from over 50 years ago, here is a photograph of a Winchester 94 I purchased new while in high school with a fairly large repair, though I’m not sure what the repair material was, the old man called it plastic and I got the gun with a discount and a few boxes of shells tossed in.
For what it is worth, the bluing is about worn off the gun, but ‘patch’ in the stock is still holding.