• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Barn Sale Find

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
What was the price of the rifle at the barn sale????
You won't find out. It was in with a dealer's lot, whereby he bought a number of items. My thought is, someone knew it was "hot", and wanted it to disappear to elsewhere. The law enforcement stolen art squad will no doubt back-track via interviews, and try to discover the ultimate sticky-fingered perp. You can see in the news accounts, the dealer who bought it had his lawyers handle the 'turn in'...so nice that it is undamaged and returned 'home'! I've been to the Rev Museum, and want to pop in to see it in person soon.
 
My question: where are the brass stars and engraving on the stock? I couldn't see any and think for a representative AWI rifle, it's perfect: minimalist and has the look of elegance and function. I know there are builders nowadays who seem to be focused on carved, chased, and highly decorated flint guns, but these a works of art...so far as I'm concerned. I figure the average rifleman in the AWI far more likely to possess a plain, well-made (at least as well made as he could afford) rifle rather than a work of art that I think are Golden Age post-war rifles made for rich folks. A display of wealth rather than one to trust his life to.

Gene, look at pictures of that gun elsewhere and you'll see a tastefully decorated rifle. The architecture does much of the talking, but it is definitely carved in a manner consistent with every other early American rifle we currently know about and more than many. You don't see a lot of inlays on 18th century American rifles, but they are not as plain as some would believe them to be. Maybe not as neatly done as their European counterparts, but carving behind the tang and behind the cheek piece are a pretty much a given. This one has carving all over.
 
So glad that antique collector was worth his weight in salt and honest to boot! I'd have probably had a heart attack if I saw that gun for sale in a barn...
 
Wouldn't it be a HOOT if it was the Rifle mentioned in this letter?

"
A 1773 Letter written by Christian Oerter, gunmaker of Christian's Spring, to Martin Bauer, friend and customer in Lancaster County PA.
This letter was discovered by Scott Paul Gordon in the Pennsylvania State Archives in the papers of Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice Jasper Yeates. It was translated from the German and published in the KRA Bulletin Vol. 38, Number 1, Fall 2011.

Below is the published translation and some thoughts on its contents.



Christiansbrunn, the 9th September, 1773

Most valued Friend Martin Baer,

At your request I have prepared [completed/finished] a good rifle and sent it over to Mr. John Hopson together with 4 pounds of Powder. The rifle is decorated [inlaid] with silver wire and well made, as well as tested and she shoots right well. It has a double trigger, so that you can fire with the triggers either unset or set. Between the triggers there is a screw with which you can make it lighter or harder to fire. There is also a ball puller with which you can pull the ball out no matter how rusty she gets. She costs 8 pounds all together and with the powder @ 3 shillings per pound makes twelve shillings, for a total of L8.12.-. Because it is very good powder I have added two pounds more than you requested. I hope it will suit you well. You can write me a couple lines to let me know how you like it. Together with friendliest greetings I am your faithful

friend and servant,

Christian Oerter

Gunmaker

_______________________________________

In the KRA Bulletin article Mr. Gordon, and coauthor Robert Lienemann, addressed questions about the identity of Martin Baer and why a man in Lancaster would request (order) a rifle from a maker in Christian’s Spring, about 90 miles away, rather than purchase one made locally. They note that the rifle’s price of 8 pounds was significantly higher than those inventoried at Christian’s Spring in May of 1773 & 1774 at 4 pounds to a bit over 5 pounds. They conclude that perhaps it was a better rifle as indicated by the wire inlay and set triggers.

This letter is an amazing find and I want to discuss a few other points it might shed light on:

The rifle was sent with 4 pounds of powder, “two pounds more than you requested” because “it is very good powder.” We usually see powder documented as something purchased at a store in the period but this leads to the conclusion that at least some gunsmiths sold/supplied powder. It also reveals that not all powder was equal and that a batch of good powder was worth stocking up on by sending twice what was requested.

The rifle was “tested” and “she shoots right well” lets us conclude that, at least in this one example, the gun maker shot the rifle enough to evaluate its accuracy. One could perhaps also conclude that in the 8 pounds “all together” Oerter was including a powder measure and ball mold.

· The detailed description of the set triggers — double lever type, firing either set or unset and explaining how they were adjusted — makes us wonder if Oerter suspected that Baer wasn’t going to be familiar with them. That in turn might shed light on how uncommon set triggers were in that region and time.

· Mentioning a ball puller that would “pull the ball out no matter how rusty she gets” leaves a lot unsaid about Oerter ‘s expectations about how the rifle, even a “good rifle” used in a well settled region far from the frontier, might be neglected.

· And, finally, Oerter repeatedly referred to the rifle as “she.” Folks involved in re-enacting and living history, who like to name their rifles, might want to keep that in mind.

http://www.flintriflesmith.com/WritingandResearch/WebArticles/1773 Letter from Gunmaker.htm

Gus
 
My question: where are the brass stars and engraving on the stock? I couldn't see any and think for a representative AWI rifle, it's perfect: minimalist and has the look of elegance and function. I know there are builders nowadays who seem to be focused on carved, chased, and highly decorated flint guns, but these a works of art...so far as I'm concerned. I figure the average rifleman in the AWI far more likely to possess a plain, well-made (at least as well made as he could afford) rifle rather than a work of art that I think are Golden Age post-war rifles made for rich folks. A display of wealth rather than one to trust his life to.

Have you seen the gun? This is a Christian Oerter rifle. Completely decorated with brass wire, in lieu of carving, as Oerter was known to do.

As far as the "average rifleman" possessing a plain rifle during this period, I believe that this is basically a modern fantasy. In that time, it was simply expected that a rifle bear at least some level of decoration. It was just the way things were done. The plain, Stickley Craftsman aesthetic was over a hundred years into their future. Plus, at that time, a rifle was expensive. Period. It made no sense whatsoever to get a plain rifle when one with the normal decoration would cost but little more (this was a very small percentage of the total cost of the gun). If you're gonna get one, might as well get a nice one. And they did.

Now, there are a FEW existing late 18th century American rifles that are relatively "plain" (my personal opinion is that these were specified by their owners to be plain as a religious expression, not to save a few pennies). It wasn't until later when the industrial revolution made locks and barrels fairly inexpensive that it became economically feasible to have a plain rifle. You may find a super plain Lehigh barn gun from the 1820's but I seriously doubt that there were ANY in the 1780's... Plus, by this later time, styles simply changed, and the guns changed with the times. ;)
 
Back
Top