MJWayne:
I used cold water and 0000 steel wool. Keep the metal wet with the Brass Black for at least 60 seconds, turns dead black. A rub with lots of cold water gives you a dark grey. My cast butt plate came out darker than I liked so I did the wash with soft scrub (the one with bleach in it). Do that quick, I tried the same trick on my nose cap,let it sit too long (the bleach) and it pitted the surface, had to re-polish (not a big deal). As I said, get some bar stock from the H/W store and practice first - although a re-polish is not all that hard. Also, try the bead blast finish, that came from the book TOTW recommended. Gives a nice finish for either browning or gray.
Mike