Yes, the 'pulling the barrel' issue is another one of those stupid debates where those who believe you should not pull a pinned barrel try to argue their opinion over those who do believe in pulling their barrels...and if they're not arguing about barrels its something else.
I did my homework on pulling pinned barrels before I ever tried it, learned and documented the steps and tips from knowledgeable people here and on other forums on how to pull pinned barrels, the cautions to take, etc. Since then I've pulled the pinned barrels for cleaning on multiple long rifles involving Early Virginias, a Dickert, and a Late Lancaster several times, no problems at all.
Ironic to the timing of this discussion though...is a realization I came to this year. Since all my barrels have been upgraded with Patent Breeches, their powder chamber and vent channel intersect in an "L" shape leaving no area below the horizontal for fouling to build up.
This eliminates any need for me to pull the barrel and soak the breech end in a bucket of water, to then pump flush it.
So to trim time off the whole cleaning process I've started experimenting just laying the rifle on its side across my carpeted work area, with the vent up.
I remove the lock & liner, swab the bore normally with wet soapy cleaning patches from the muzzle like usual, then wrap a wet cleaning patch around a .32cal brush and looking in through the vent channel can see the cleaning patch come all the way down through the P/B powder chamber and bottom out in the vent channel each time.
Then I get the vent channel with a couple Q-tips, and dry & lube the same way.
So far, so good...takes a lot less time and I have no worries about water getting anywhere it shouldn't. I'll still pull the barrels periodically as I like to check under them routinely, keep them coated with lithium grease, etc. So, as a side benefit of patent breeches, I believe I've discovered a very simple yet thorough way to clean my particular Flintlock barrels.
But bottom line, if you learn how to do it, get the right size straight punch to push the pins out, use caution not to booger up the stock, pinned barrels can be routinely removed with no problem at all.
NOTE: I have no personal interest in whether or not anyone else ever pulls a pinned barrel, just clarifying for the record that it’s not rocket science.
:wink: