I normally prefer more traditional designs, but I like this model of pistol. I have a couple of older CVA rifles that I like very much. They are solid, accurate shooters. The adjustable rear sight and "finger hook" trigger guard should help make the CVA Hawken pistol a good target shooter.
I don't own a Trapper or a Patriot, but I do have a Lyman Plains Pistol. The lock, barrel, and trigger are great, and it is a very solid pistol. The OEM sights on the Plains Pistol are terrible, but can be replaced. The grip has all the ergonomics of a cane handle, with an almost perfectly round cross-section. For me, the trigger reach is too long and I have difficulty achieving a repeatable hand position. However, I know a lot of people love the Plains Pistol, and shoot it very well.
It would be great if Pecatonica would develop a replacement stock for the Lyman Plains Pistol, with nicer wood and a better grip.
Regarding the pistols in the photos in posts #1 and 4, above, I see some differences. The forend in the first one appears to have been shortened... There is a gap between the end of the rib and the nosecap, and the nosecap is closer to the wedge escutcheon than on the second pistol, and it looks like it is made of brass. It may just be he light and reflection, but the second pistol seems to have the nosecap and wedge escutcheons made of white metal(s). The ramrod pipe also looks shorter on the first pistol. However, none of those points should affect its shootability.
I'll be interested in comments made by others.
Best regards,
Notchy Bob