Files into knives

[bramble]

A question that I've always had (& fellows, I really don't have a dog in this fight) is why a reenactor would antique anything.
It seems that in any given period of history, the equipment they used would be the equivalent of what we'd buy or make today (in the sense of newness). For example, in the War for Southern Independence a soldier would not be carrying an Enfield with a great patina and aged stock, it would be a relatively new firearm, even though it might be a little beat up by use.

Just wondering

Merry Christmas
bramble

 

[LRB]

Because, when you are reenacting at a public event, it just looks a bit odd if you are a market hunter and everything is spotless clean and shiny. Things just look more believable when there is noticable grunge and wear on the items and clothing.

 

[k.jacobfrost]

You might have more success and less damage to the blade if you force the dagger through GAPS in the armor or chain mail!

I really can not remember the last time this situation presented itself in more than an academic mode.

And I hope the person occupying it has a forgiving nature.

You are correct, finding kinks and gaps in armor is the preferred method of use, and I do not intend to or foresee actually having to do this (academic reasons aside). I just think that if I am going to put the time and effort into making one, then it should also be "functional" as well.

I would also think finding somebody who would have a forgiving nature of that caliber would be better to keep around, if only for use in less permanent academic "research". :grin:

 

[bramble]

Wick,
Thanks for the reply.

Grunge, dirt, dings, etc. I can see as essential. But I view the look of heavy use and the look of antique as different. I'd think that a five year old rifle that has been used, abused, and in constant service would look quite different from an identical model that is one hundred years old.

Like I said, this is just curiosity. I haven't the bucks to invest in vintage arms, and haven't the time to get into reenacting (though I'd love to do both). I do appreciate folks taking the time to help me think through this one.

Merry Christmas
bramble