First BP Revolver: Uberti NMA in Stainless?

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Mustakrakish

32 Cal
Joined
Mar 4, 2021
Messages
23
Reaction score
15
I'm brand new to cap and ball. Good choice? Bad choice? I've already placed the order with DGW, but I'm having some doubts as to whether or not the order will actually ship, as I've noticed that since I made the order the Uberti is no longer in stock, the price has changed, and northern Italy is now locked down again. The Uberti seemed like a good option for ringing plates and making smoke while perhaps not being quite as persnickety about corrosion due to the stainless steel, but that assessment was based on internet research.

On a related note, why aren't there more BP guns in stainless? I'm guessing that it's because they don't sell, but I'm wondering why they don't sell.
 
I have purchased a few things from Dixie over the past year, and in my experience if the item was in stock when you checked out then the item is "saved" for you until it ships. So even if it is showing out of stock now the item is still in the queue waiting to be shipped.

I think a lot of people assume stainless will not rust, and as such are a little too lax about cleaning. I have a Pietta stainless I bought used and has some nice corrosion in the bore because some previous owner had this train of thought, apparently.

Stainless is of course rust resistant, not rust proof. Stainless steel still contains carbon and most certainly will rust - especially some of the "lower-grade" stainless, like I'm sure they use in these comparatively inexpensive revolvers.

As a result, I treat my stainless revolvers exactly the same as I do my blued steel revolvers, and all get cleaned just as thoroughly and timely.

As to why they are not more popular, I think part of it is that most of us that like percussion revolvers want them to be like the originals - so that means blued steel. But I think the bigger reason is that they are just flat out more expensive.

I think the overwhelming majority of BP revolvers are sold to - shall we say non-enthusiasts. I know it is hard to comprehend for folks like us who really enjoy shooting, but I'd say close to 80-90% of all firearms made throughout history have seen no more than a box or two of ammo run through them, and spend the rest of their lives living in the back of a sock drawer.

Even amongst people that like to shoot and shoot often, percussion revolvers are still thought of as nothing more than novelties or toys, so spending $500+ for a stainless percussion revolver that might get brought out to the range no more than once or twice a year just isn't practical for most of these people. For them, the $250 brass frame 1851 is far more reasonable. Therefore, Pietta and Uberti just don't make a lot of stainless revolvers because people don't really buy them.
 
Yea they are about a month out, but it ships. I did an order last night myself. A lot of guns came available.

Yea very few people who are into the history itself are into stainless because it just just doesn't look right. They make the stainless ones because there is only one pattern that people buy to carry, because they can't get cartridge firearms, or they are a felon. It is the 58 Remington. The cylinders swap out without tools, and you can even get cartridge cylinders for them. It's just a practical matter, even though the internals are not stainless.

Clean the gun the same day anyway, even shooting pyrodex or triple7.
 
The advantage with stainless steel is that it is easier to clean--the fouling doesn't stick to the metal as badly as it does regular steel. These 1860 Colts are expensive--one I have had for many years and it has been fired frequently yet still looks unused. The other one below it has not been fired and both guns look the same. My shooter gets disassembled and cleaned after each use.
1860Armys.jpg
 
Very good information all around. I appreciate it.

Jdesero's observation on rust got me thinking to the times when I've gotten rust on my unmentionables, both stainless and carbon steel. I live in the PNW and shoot outdoors year round, which means that for 2/3 of the year, I'm normally shooting in the rain...which raises another question: are caps reliable in the rain? Bear in mind that this is gentle Washington rain that I'm talking about, and not cow-urinating-on-a-flat-rock east coast rain.
 
Back
Top