Handgun reloader meets leadball

[Blueforge]

a newbie question for ya'll. Having loaded handgun cartridges for years, the bullet diameter should remain the same and only the projectile weight changes. It fits or you run the risk of a clogged barrel. Along comes the holy black muzzelloaders! Ball size, patch size, tighter, looser, grouping, distance, etc. My question is: How tight should ball and patch be in the barrel. Loose fit gives me lousy accuracy but every time I get to having to really pound it in I get the heebies and visions of a clogged barrel detonation. For out in the field, just how tight is too tight?

 

[R Ellis]

seems you need just a snug fit not loose or tight try a different ball diameter and also patch material .Could you share what caliber and what ball size and patch thickness that you have tried and the results

 

[Grenadier1758]

@Blueforge, you have been on the forum for a while. Since you are talking of patched balls, I am thinking that you are talking about a single shot pistol. With a single shot pistol that is using soft lead balls that are patched over suitable propellant such as black powder or the equivalent substitute, there won't be a problem of a clogged bore. It really only takes 5 grains of powder by volume to send a ball out of a rifle barrel. As @R Ellis says, a snug fit is what is required for a pistol. There's no accuracy in a loose fit. Far too much blow by of the powder to be effective.

 

[Sooty Scot]

To clarify "snug" a bit, you should still be able to push the patched ball down. If you're having to pound it down, it's too tight - in my opinion.
I suggest you try adjusting the other factors (1 at a time, of course)- Patch thickness and lubrication. You could also try a slightly smaller or larger ball diameter.
Are you familiar with the "dry" patch lubing technique? Many swear by that for teasing out the final bit of accuracy.

Hope this is helpful.

 

[bpd303]

If you are worried about a gap between the powder and ball which can cause a detonation which can happen. Load a loose round that is definitely seated on the powder and make a mark on the ram rod at the muzzle, That way you can be sure of a good seated load. Used mostly with rifles but works with single shot pistols too.

 

[M. De Land]

a newbie question for ya'll. Having loaded handgun cartridges for years, the bullet diameter should remain the same and only the projectile weight changes. It fits or you run the risk of a clogged barrel. Along comes the holy black muzzelloaders! Ball size, patch size, tighter, looser, grouping, distance, etc. My question is: How tight should ball and patch be in the barrel. Loose fit gives me lousy accuracy but every time I get to having to really pound it in I get the heebies and visions of a clogged barrel detonation. For out in the field, just how tight is too tight?

The best answer I have ever come across and have always used and found reliable is tight enough that the weave of your patch material should imprint both groove and land on the ball exterior. If it imprints only on the land portion of ball contact it is not thick enough to form a perfect gas seal. If recovered patches are torn or holed than they are not the correct thickness assuming only cotton cloth is being used and the barrel is broken in.
Patch material should always be of cotton and tight of weave so light does not readily pass through when held up to a source.
I have found nothing better than old cotton shirt felt about ..018 thick so keep all my work shirts when worn out to make patches with. They work equally well if made into strips and cut at the muzzle or punched out round patches.
A properly fit cotton patch of the correct thickness and tightness of weave can be picked up, cleaned and used again although the edges will be frayed.
My go to patch lube year round is blue windshield wash containing water, soap and alcohol (no peroxide).

 

[Mike in FL]

If a really tight load works well, that's what I'd use. Maybe I missed it, but I didn't see where you said you had to pound the ball down the barrel.

 

[Maven]

Having had to use a plastic mallet, longer short starter, and steel ramrod to load my rifle yesterday, I wasn't happy or looking forward to completing the postal match. The ball - patch combination was much too tight (but accurate!). For bench rest and demanding shooting, the tight ball - patch seems to be favored, but for Load from a Bag Shoots and Woods Walks, not so much. Black Powder Mainiac uses a looser combination and has made a believer out of me.

 

[wiscoaster]

..... It fits or you run the risk of a clogged barrel. ..... every time I get to having to really pound it in I get the heebies and visions of a clogged barrel detonation. ....

I've never heard of such a risk with a muzzleloader. IMO if you can ram it down it will shoot out.

 

[TNGhost]

I've never heard of such a risk with a muzzleloader. IMO if you can ram it down it will shoot out.

No risk, so long as it is firmly on top of the powder

 

[westrayer]

Mark the ramrod at the end of the muzzle when you load whatever load you are using. If the ring marked on the ramrod is exposed, then the ball is not seated.
Ball/patch combo is one of those things that you will need to explore. Say a .50 cal. 490" and .020" patch or a .495" ball and a .015" patch? Tight fitting combo is best for accuracy but once you use the ball seater, and it is hard to seat with a ramrod than you have over done it.
Look at a pneumatic ball discharger. I always carry one with me too the range and hunting. The first time that you seat a ball without powder, you will thank me. Beats having to take out the touch hole and try to get enough powder in there to shoot it out.

 

[French Colonial]

One of the simplest things in the world, mark your ramrod.

 

[wiscoaster]

.....
Look at a pneumatic ball discharger. I always carry one with me too the range and hunting.

Just wondering if you've ever had to use it. I bought one once and had opportunity to use it and it didn't work for me. I ended up using the grease gun method.

 

[Ohio Rusty]

I bet I shot thousands of powder puff loads of 38 special using a round ball. We would reprime the case with a primer, dump in a 22 LR case full of Unique powder. We used a soft lead .360 round ball as the case is .357 and it would be a tight fit. We used a common bench vise to press fit the ball in the end of the case. Put the case length wise in the vice and close the jaws. That would press fit the ball flush with the end of the case. We had a .22 bullet trap in the basement an it was a hoot to shoot these into the trap. Knocked over lots of plastic army men targets.
Ohio Rusty ><>