How to tell if this is real or replica

[Rachael]

My husband and I are collectors and came across this we are pretty sure it is a replica of an 18th century flintlock pistol, but we are not sure anyrhing about it. We would love to know anything about it. Please help.

 

[Flintlock Fellow]

My husband and I are collectors and came across this we are pretty sure it is a replica of an 18th century flintlock pistol, but we are not sure anyrhing about it. We would love to know anything about it. Please help.
View attachment 371386View attachment 371387View attachment 371388

The clearest indicator that this is a replica is the frizzen “spring,” which is molded directly into the lock plate rather than functioning as a true spring. Additionally, the barrel lacks a drilled touch hole, confirming its inability to fire. This piece is a non-functional wall hanger, intended purely for decorative purposes.

 

[Rancocas]

Yes. What Flintlock Fellow said. ^^^

 

[Kansas Jake]

Other indicators are the level of finish to the barrel and wood. There is a difference once you see it between age related rust or patina and pieces made to look old. This is especially true for cheaply made wall hangers. Antiques will normally show evidence of once being smoothly finished and sharpness around the lock etc. even if well worn or even abused.

 

[Absoroka]

looks like the designs are milled into the barrel and filled with paint, Also, the frizzen shows only a few scuffs and the pan shows no wear. Looks like they dipped it in some chemical to "age" it.

 

[wiscoaster]

Nevertheless, it's pretty .... clean it up, mount it in a frame, and hang it on your wall.

 

[morehops52]

I agree. It's a nice display piece. I'd bet 95% of the folks who see it won't know what it really is.

 

[PathfinderNC]

What do you collect?

 

[Rachael]

What do you collect?

Anything and everything older than 1950

 

[Rachael]

The clearest indicator that this is a replica is the frizzen “spring,” which is molded directly into the lock plate rather than functioning as a true spring. Additionally, the barrel lacks a drilled touch hole, confirming its inability to fire. This piece is a non-functional wall hanger, intended purely for decorative purposes.

Thank you!!

 

[sethwyo]

Heap of these made in Mexico in the mid 1900s, non firing made from cast. Sold to tourist an people looking for treasures. I don't figure this is pre 1950, I believe it's 1960s thru 70s.

Is the 'wood' on it real wood ? Or resin ?

Not a worthless piece of junk. Well made piece of art an It has a value from That time in the USA for anyone reminiscing about life in that time.