btech said:
Probably gonna commit some cardinal sins. I want a gun that looks good and shoots good.
Ooooh, yes, no matter what you do with it there is most likely going to be someone who disputes what you may do. There is one wing of the collecting fraternity who firmly states one should do nothing more than keep the gun in the condition it is and just preserve it from further deterioration. Bottom line, though, it is now your pistol and you are the one who decides on what will be done.
About 3 years ago I was handed a shoe box by a good friend and fellow traveler who asked if I could complete the reconversion of an M1836 Johnson Pistol, which was the immediate predecessor of your "new" pistol. The Widow of another traveler asked if my friend could find someone to finish it as her husband worked on it for many years and never completed it before his passing. She wanted to frame it in remembrance of her husband.
The mainspring was gone, the sear tip was completed busted off, the screw for the butt cap was missing, the stock had major cracks, the previous owner or someone else had "cleaned" off about 3/4 of the original surface metal of the barrel and most of the stock finish, just to name some of the things I ran into. So I wasn't doing a restoration or reconversion as much as the job turned out to be a rescue.
I buy antique gun parts to use later and fortunately I had purchased two original butt cap screws about two years earlier that were either for the M1836 or M1842 series of pistols. Either would have worked very nicely, but one was an almost perfect fit. I just happened to go to a Civil War Collector's show and found three original sears for these pistols. One worked great without modification so that's the one that went in. Dixie had a repro mainspring that BARELY was long enough for the rear end of the spring to stay on the tumbler when the lock was cocked, but it was long enough. Though I normally don't like to use Cold Blue on originals, Brownell's Oxpho Blue and some "adjustment" of it evened out the metal finish on the barrel without doing more serious damage to the original metal. I used Renaissance Wax on stock with some real refined linseed oil There were other things I had to fix as I went along, but I won't bore folks with the details.
When it was finished, it was a working pistol that looked a whole lot better than it did when it came to me. I returned the broken original parts and pieces and suggested the Widow keep those in the "shadow box" she made for the pistol. Her joy to see the pistol completed to honor her husband, more than made up for the far reduced price I charged her for the work.
So good luck in your restoration as I know how rewarding it can be.
Gus