Kibler kits are the best kits out their for a new builder, most other take varying degrees of building experience to do them justice. As Jim expands his selection of kits there will soon be something for most muzzleloadening folks. SMR not my cup of tea, Colonial is great, and Woodsrunner even better. As far as style, historical look, and caliber selection. Can't wait to see if he makes a smooth bore, and a Plains rifle / Hawkens at some point. Maybe he will even develop a percussion lock some day?
Unfortunely as Jim can turn out so many cookie cutter guns with his manufacturing process, you loose some of the "personality". That is where YOU as the builder come into play. Learn to carve, I am struggling with that right now. Go to shows and museums to see how you want to finish Jim's kits. That is part of the fun in this hobby.
My three words of advice:
1. Jim's kits are the best game in town for the newbie. Quality, price, and ease!
2. Do your research, take your time and you can have a very special semi-custom piece
3. Don't count on making money, all muzzleloaders - if used they depreciate in my opinion. Black powder and how we clean them put miles on these firearms. I feel if I can have enjoyment in building, shooting them, and I break even on the cost of the kit and finishing materials it is a win- win.
On my second Kibler build, a smooth bore Colonial. Wish I had a Woodsrunner instead (length as a deer hunter). Tempted to cut six to 8 inches off my Colonial, part of that customizing. Weight and length is a little too long and heavy for deer hunting in the woods of Pennsylvania. Or maybe just finish it, sell it and buy a Woodsrunner? But they are all the rage these days, especially with the carving option.