Trent: Are you talking about true case hardening, and the colors, or the fake paint that is being done on some modern species? Real case hardening hardens the surface to a glass hard finish, although its usually very thin. The color is the result of oxides that occur when the metal is held in contact with carbon under great heat. You can remove the finish colors, but the metal itself may still be hard as a rock! To my best knowledge, the only way to truly reverse a case hardened part is to heat it up to it maleable temperature, and then cool it slowly to anneal it. The problem with case hardening any iron or steel component is the chance that the metal will warp during the cooling process. You can usually only Re-case harden steel parts once. After that, you stand a better than average chance that the part will develop stress cracks, and be worthless. Apparently the repeated heating and then cooling draws out too much of the carbon leaving the metal brittle. At least that is How Oscar Gaddy explained it to me.