Thank you Zonie. I think that is a fair assessment. #11 seems right since the existing nipple top stack OD is about 0.165" (but having too much taper downward). One of the fellows suggested the hammer may not be an original and appears offset to the nipple. So, if this is the case I hope the hammer won't give me any grieve once I installBased on this photo you provided, a #11 cap is what you want to use.
The nose of the hammer isn't large enough to work well with a musket size cap.
Hmmm. I learn something more every time I log onto this website. Thank you