• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Shopping for a pistol

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Slake

45 Cal.
Joined
Mar 4, 2006
Messages
651
Reaction score
1
I am in a pistol buying mode and in my shopping I see Deer creek has Heritage Pistol Kits. I'm not familiar with Heritage.Any advice? I'm thinking of getting a kit for one of my sons as a gift. I don't care for myself if I get a kit or not. I am looking at 45 or 50's but I'm open to any suggestions. I like the Kentucky style full stock look but I also like the wedge pin concept for easy cleaning and take down
 
Slake,

Last Deer Creek catalog I got didn't have the pistols you are referring to. In fact they didn't have a lot of guns they used to have.

Don
 
2006 catalog, I just got it, on page one they had Heritage Pistol Kits
 
Hello to Saratoga Springs (I lived just South of you for 10 years).

Rule # 1 - All pistols are fun, provided they work.

Rule # 2 - build a loading stand, you will never regret it.

I have a 45-cal percussion and a 44 cal cap-n'-ball revolver, plus enough firearms and air pistols to make even my very tolerant wife ask, "When will it stop?"

The cap-n'-ball revolver is the most fun of all, the 44 magnum centerfire is the most stimulating to shoot, the air pistols are the most spontaneous cause I can shoot them on a moment's notice without driving to the range.

No experience with the guns you mentioned, but if the group here says they are reliable then I don't think you can go wrong.

Good luck and have fun.
 
I will have the stand...I'm not sure how you'd go about it without it honestly. I have handguns now. I have more revolvers than pistols {semi autos} but I haven't any blackpower pistols yet. I've used them. I almost bought a Ruger Old Army ball and cap revolver then I found out my club doesn't allow them at bp shoots {too modern?}
 
Just a thought, look at the Traditions Trapper kit. Not expensive, easy to build, Shoots great and has a set trigger for target shooting. :hmm:
 
Deer Creeks pistol kits are okay if you are looking for something to play with. If you are looking for a gun to shoot copetively or interested in accracy I would look else where. The lock is the same one that Traditions uses in there guns at least I took the one out of my pistol and it fit in my kentucky.

Berk
 
Jeez, they must of sent you the good catalog. Mine didn't have any of the Heratidge guns or the Mowerys and six pages of the same civil war accoutiment stuff.

Don
 
You may want to consider a Lyman Great Plains Pistol. They have a 1:30 twist and hold very nicely. I have one in .54 cal to go with my GPR.
 
Oh yes the Lyman GPR pistol is nice and strong.There is earlier posts of Deer hunting loads.
 
Another vote for the Lyman Plains Pistol. I have one in a 50 Cal. At 20 Yards it is dead on. Nice tight groups. My wasn't a kit, but kits are available.
 
I'd second Russainblood on the Lyman GPR and recommend 54 cal. if you're only going to have one pistol......which probably isn't likely after you get your first, (ask me how I know that!). The GPR kits are mostly easy to assemble and mine is as accurate as any of my better modern revolvers.

Vic
 
I've noticed the Lymans are a few dollars more than a lot of 'em I was wondering if that equated to quality. The one I was looking at is called the Plains pistol. I like the wedge pin design for easy takedown cleaning, but I also like the full stock Kentucky look
 
You may also want to consider if a double trigger config is important to your type of planned shooting. I know that the Traditions' Trapper model has a set trigger config. Both the Plains and Trapper have recieved positive reviews on this forum.
 
I have yet to use double triggers. I'm intrigued with the concept and would think they would be slick on a rifle but a pistol? Really? Tell me why. I don't know that much about them. I was amazed to see them on pistols
 

Latest posts

Back
Top