My favorite is the Brown Bess. When I first started shooting flintlocks about 4 years ago, my first gun was a Charleville. I just flat out didn't like that gun, so I got myself a Brown Bess, and have been happy with it every since. The one that I have was made about 30 years ago, and has been 'defarbed' so there are no makers marks anywhere on it. In fact, in comparing it to some originals at the Frazier Historical Arms museum, it is closer in looks and coloring to the originals. The current Pedersoli repros LOOK like repros. I went to Friendship with the idea of picking up either a French Tulle, or a Northwest Trade Gun, but after looking them over for several hours, I could not bring myself to spend the $800 plus bucks for one, especially considering that I had something MUCH BETTER at home, that cost me a lot less!!!So, I am a Brown Bess man, but I must admit that some of those 'Smooth Rifles' are rather appealing.....