Maybe. I’ve long preferred Uberti over Pietta. But the recent efforts from both manufacturers are very good quality. At least those I’ve seen. I would expect CNC manufacturing would give them both the opportunity at least to provide consistent quality, fit and finish.
That being said, I would hesitate to buy any secondhand stuff online at least for the present time. To many people are unloading the pieces of junk they’ve had languishing under the workbench or in the basement...
I attest to that. Im looking for a Uberti 1858 5.5 for some time now and on another forum I was offered several older pieces that were obviously not up to the mark and were being dumped as solid examples.