walnut versus maple carving

[thecapgunkid]

Any advice regarding the difference in working walnut versus curly maple in rifle carving?

Thanks

Greg

 

[Rifleman1776]

Among carvers this is as cussed and discussed a subject as lubes are with ml'ers.
Those who carve things like busts and statues seem to prefer walnut. It requires a different technique and tools that are not as sharp as used with other woods.
My rifle builder won't touch walnut, he preferes maple and the carving he does on that is to marvel at. Go figger. :idunno:
Get some scraps and test and decide for yerself.

 

[LRB]

Walnut takes more care in the carving, and a razor sharp knife, chisels, gouges, ect. It is very prone to small splinter like chipping. Go slow and careful and it generally is not a problem. Be especially alert to grain direction. In my experience.

 

[Stophel]

Yep, walnut will chip off really bad. And since it doesn't have the same "body" as something like sugar maple, it is harder to carve as well.

One thing I have noticed is that carving on black walnut never looks as sharp and clean as on sugar maple, even when it is sharp and clean. I haven't quite figured that one out....

European walnut will cut much crisper and cleaner than American black walnut. But, the only European walnut wood I have is a few old Mauser stocks, so I don't get to carve it much! :grin:

 

[MSW]

I like Rifleman1776's advice ... try a bit of each and see which works best for your particular application.

Whichever you choose, you'll need to get your tools scary sharp- neurosurgery sharp, and never hesitate to take a minute to strop an edge!

Good luck with your project, and let us know how it turns out (we like pictures).