Okay: I show in my charts that a 12 gauge is .729" in diameter, so his gauge figure is probably technically correct. I show a 72 caliber barrel weighing 550 grains, .715" in diameter, with a B/C of .084, and a Sectional Density of .153. There are obviously, slight differences in weight, and diameter, reflected in a small difference in the Ballistics Coefficient he got( .83 vs. .84).
Fort those who don't sit around working with a computer figuring out these kinds of numbers, using either BC is going to give you as close a look to actual trajectories over 100-150 yards as any computer model can do. In real environment, you will be dealing with not only trajectory, but relative humidity, and winds. A tail wind, coming in from behind you, will cause the ball to fly a bit flatter. A head win will cause the ball to drop faster. Any kind of cross wind will move the ball further to the right or left than the drop of the ball over these distances.
So, while computing drop of given powder charges in various caliber guns is a fun exercise to do on a rainy day, in the field its the least of your problems to diagnose in order to take a good shot at a deer, or any other game animal.