Shot the old Lyman 54 some yesterday

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
Nov 14, 2019
Messages
185
Reaction score
280
Location
West Tennessee - Memphis Area
Went to the son-in-law's farm yesterday and shot about 25 rounds. Just shooting beer cans off hand. I have both .530 and .535 balls. I was just trying to decide if I could tell the difference loading them but I couldn't

I have never been able to load more than 2 without swabbing the boar so a while back I tried polishing the bore with fine scotch Brite as shown by Dualist 54 in his video. I did a hundred strokes with the red fine scotch Brite. I guess that wasn't enough cause I am still having to clean between shots
 
Forgot the picture
 

Attachments

  • 20240927_152417.jpg
    20240927_152417.jpg
    2.8 MB
If you can’t load more then two your doing something wrong. What’s all the details of your load? I shoot an entire match without swabbing so it can be done.

Well I am somewhat to to this and have the same issues.

Seems to be a patch thickness to ball diameter thing vs actual bore size. Guess one could go with smaller dia. ball and a thinner patch material to get a .010" smaller ball/patch combo. The barrel's bore would be another thing to question?
 
Burrs/rough bore is a common problem in investarms guns. They are quite accurate but hard to load more than a couple of rounds without cleaning. Dulalist54 has documented this in his fix video. I used finer scotch Brite than he did and less strokes. Going to do a hundred more.
 
Last edited:
If you can’t load more then two your doing something wrong. What’s all the details of your load? I shoot an entire match without swabbing so it can be done.
Phil

I am loading 110 grs of Graff fffg , .535 and .530 balls , .015 pillow ticking patch, old CVA #11 CAPS ( THESE ARE CCI'S ). This load is very accurate in my gun .
 
Phil

I am loading 110 grs of Graff fffg , .535 and .530 balls , .015 pillow ticking patch, old CVA #11 CAPS ( THESE ARE CCI'S ). This load is very accurate in my gun .
That's an awfully heavy load, jb. No wonder you can't get more than 2 shots without swabbing your bore. I think I'd drop down to 100gr. FFg and try a wet lube, e.g., spit, "moose milk," etc. If wet patch lube isn't your preference, Google "Stumpy's Moose Snot," which is easy to concoct and is good for 8* shots before you'll need to swab the bore. Just some food for thought...
 
For plinking try 50gr powder and spit patch, i can shoot all day without cleaning. What do the shot patches look like?
 
I was thinking about trying some olive oil. Her Majesty has 3 bottles.
You are probably not going to see any difference with it. You need to use a wet lube. Spit is the simplest and everyone has an unlimited lifetime supply. Just pop the patch in your mouth and saturate it. This will wipe the fouling from the previous shot as you load the next.

There are other options than spit.

What's important to consider is how long it will be loaded. Are you shooting only at the range or hunting? If hunting you want a lube that is not water based but in a more liquid form. Hoppes black powder patch lube is a good one.

https://www.walmart.com/ip/Hoppes-N...8c6897d11e141d221492f129828f2b08&gclsrc=3p.ds
 
Went to the son-in-law's farm yesterday and shot about 25 rounds. Just shooting beer cans off hand. I have both .530 and .535 balls. I was just trying to decide if I could tell the difference loading them but I couldn't

I have never been able to load more than 2 without swabbing the boar so a while back I tried polishing the bore with fine scotch Brite as shown by Dualist 54 in his video. I did a hundred strokes with the red fine scotch Brite. I guess that wasn't enough cause I am still having to clean between shots
You have a lot of advice already. For my 54, fun shooting and targets, I use 60gns of FFG, a 530 roundball, a spit lubed .018 patch (pillow ticking), and an overthrow of semolina (about a teaspoon's worth); using the overthrow of semolina, you can be as generous as you want with your spit - slobber away @jambuster and let us know how you get on. Oh, and I gave up on the 535 balls because they didn't add to accuracy, oft times making it harder to load as the shot numbers got higher.

Cheers, Pete
 
Your are shooting an overload. Per the Lyman manual for the .54 GPR the maximum loading of 3F is 100 grains. This is on PDF that I tried to post but it will not do so. That may be part of the fouling issue. The other is the .015 patches instead of .018 patches. Have you inspected any recovered patches? That can be very helpful in determining the proper patch thickness and material required for optimum.

My .54 GPR loves 90 Grains of 3F, .530 RB, .018 ticking and TOTW Mink Oil. Before I tried a lower powder charge and didn't achieve the great accuracy I have now.

Second. I know you are interested in finding a load that you can shoot more repetitively without having to wipe the bore. It that's your goal, then try some other patch lube such as spit or something with a cleaner in it. For hunting, stick with a good lube such as mink oil, olive oil/beeswax mixture or bear grease and leave the spit in your mouth and cleaners under your sink. I do strongly suggest you do your final test shooting and sight-in prior to hunting season with whatever patch lube you plan on hunting with.

Personally, I have no issues with running a moist patch that has Windex on it after a few shots, then follow up with a couple of dry patches. Unless one is competition shooting or perhaps doing a woods-walk shoot, it's no big deal to run a patch down the bore after a few shots. Even then I would still choose to run a moist patch down the bore after a few shots if time permits. I can promise you one thing. After I do the above, regardless of how many shots I've fired, at the end of the day and come time to clean, all of my ML's have little fouling that comes out.

Thirdly, Swiss powder has proven to me to be cleaner than at least GOEX. Never tried Gaffs. Either way, Swiss is a cleaner burning powder.

Good luck.
 
Last edited:
Your are shooting an overload. Per the Lyman manual for the .54 GPR the maximum loading of 3F is 100 grains. This is on PDF that I tried to post but it will not do so. That may be part of the fouling issue. The other is the .015 patches instead of .018 patches. Have you inspected any recovered patches? That can be very helpful in determining the proper patch thickness and material required for optimum.

My .54 GPR loves 90 Grains of 3F, .530 RB, .018 ticking and TOTW Mink Oil. Before I tried a lower powder charge and didn't achieve the great accuracy I have now.

Second. I know you are interested in finding a load that you can shoot more repetitively without having to wipe the bore. It that's your goal, then try some other patch lube such as spit or something with a cleaner in it. For hunting, stick with a good lube such as mink oil, olive oil/beeswax mixture or bear grease and leave the spit in your mouth and cleaners under your sink. I do strongly suggest you do your final test shooting and sight-in prior to hunting season with whatever patch lube you plan on hunting with.

Personally, I have no issues with running a moist patch that has Windex on it after a few shots, then follow up with a couple of dry patches. Unless one is competition shooting or perhaps doing a woods-walk shoot, it's no big deal to run a patch down the bore after a few shots. Even then I would still choose to run a moist patch down the bore after a few shots if time permits. I can promise you one thing. After I do the above, regardless of how many shots I've fired, at the end of the day and come time to clean, all of my ML's have little fouling that comes out.

Thirdly, Swiss powder has proven to me to be cleaner than at least GOEX. Never tried Gaffs. Either way, Swiss is a cleaner burning powder.

Good luck.
1000007698.jpg
Those are some of the patches from. FRIDAY. These are a precut .015 pillow ticking. I think they came from TOW.

My Lyman instructions and black powder manual both indicate that 110grs of fffg is a suitable load. I've read before that some manuals recommend a lower charge but I've shot this one enough to where I'm not worried about it. I do have a can of GOEX i could try. I got the graff's a while back and it shoots fine. I've got several pounds so I'm gonna keep using it for the time being.
 
Last edited:
Those patches look okay overall. However, that does not mean you’re not getting some blow by, perhaps that is causing more fouling. If it were me, I’d still try some .018 quality ticking. The tighter patch/ball, the better, generally speaking.

Unless this manual has been superseded, 100 grains of 3F listed is the maximum load and came directly from the Lyman manual PDF. Loader up all you want. It’s your party, bro. 90 grains is plenty for most .54 GPR, as well as very accurate.

Target from 75 yards. The hole at 0900 was an oops. I wasn’t ready to pull the trigger.

Good luck.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1399.jpeg
    IMG_1399.jpeg
    1.1 MB
  • IMG_2581.jpeg
    IMG_2581.jpeg
    1.5 MB
  • IMG_2583.jpeg
    IMG_2583.jpeg
    2.9 MB
Last edited:
Same area I’m in… Farm is on the Tipton/Shelby line.
I’ve found 90gr of 3F Swiss or T7 is sufficient. Same poi as 120gr 2F subs.
For my .54 GPR, 90gr powder, t-shirt patch, T17 lube over the patch, .530 swaged Hornady ball, CCI #11 magnum cap. Barrel is sooty, but not fouled out. Putting the lube over the patch, the ball will push enough goop through the fabric to grab/hold previous shot debris. And not leave a greasy mess behind. I use the same for pre-fab sewn ball loading. Patch, T17, ball, make it look like a dumpling, wrap thread around over the ball.
Will be using for the quarterly hog shoot in Hardin County come November.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top