.58 Colonial is a heart breaker
- Thread starter Buff1958
- Start date
Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:
How far did it go after that heart shot?
Too bad you wasted the heart and not the liver!
Too bad you wasted the heart and not the liver!
that rifle definitely called down the thunder. Well done 
Sweet!
50 yard half circleHow far did it go after that heart shot?
Too bad you wasted the heart and not the liver!
- Joined
- Aug 27, 2004
- Messages
- 3,274
- Reaction score
- 7,306
Hope you weren't planning on the family eating heart.
- Joined
- Mar 13, 2020
- Messages
- 7,529
- Reaction score
- 21,145
- Location
- On the Border in Idaho looking at BC
that right there is why we always shot deer in the head back in the 50's and 60's! blow up a heart like that and momma would take a strip off with a willow switch.
that is some definite medicine right there. biggest hole i have made in a critter was .54 going in. didn't check the going out size.
just wanted to add that this post is in no way denigrating the OP and his success. maybe a little jealousy but that is a great score!
that is some definite medicine right there. biggest hole i have made in a critter was .54 going in. didn't check the going out size.
just wanted to add that this post is in no way denigrating the OP and his success. maybe a little jealousy but that is a great score!
Last edited:
FF1612
32 Cal
Sweeeeeet!!
Great shot! Congratulations and another flintlock kill.
BJHabermehl
40 Cal
That’s why I aim for the center of the heart-lung “ football”. Usually taking out the aorta and both lungs. I like my pickled deer heart. I also hunt with a .58 cal flintlock rifle. Usually they go down in sight. BJH
Nice shooting
aussie pete
40 Cal
Some of you lads are having some wonderful hunts lately. That's a good amount of protein there @Buff1958. Great shot too - no use lamenting it; some meat loss is usually expected.
Cheers, Pete
To each there own . For me there is Nothing better than fresh deer liver.How far did it go after that heart shot?
Too bad you wasted the heart and not the liver!
Congrats!
As the character "Marv" from the movie "Home Alone - Lost in New York" said: WOW...WHAT A HOLE!!!
As the character "Marv" from the movie "Home Alone - Lost in New York" said: WOW...WHAT A HOLE!!!
I got one from a steep slope once killed it three times with one shot spine, aorta, lungs exit lower chest rt frnt leg , dead befor I heard the shot 25 to 30 yds. A very nice forked horn largest fork antlers I ever saw. Near Shelter Cove Calif . About 140# at final dusk, barely time to field dress.
Back to Eureka for fresh liver.
HighUintas
45 Cal.
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2022
- Messages
- 516
- Reaction score
- 579
Is that the entry? What was the load and how far was the shot?
I'm planning on loading 125gr 2f in my 58 for my first hunt with it. I'm wondering what to expect at 50 yards on a deer. Similar to a slug, or total destruction?
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2010
- Messages
- 5,362
- Reaction score
- 5,115
As Elmer Keith used to say, " you can eat right up to the bullet hole!"
Don't let the chest-beaters bring you down. While they're waiting for the perfect Liver shot , which according to anatomy is in the Guts, you brought home the venison.
Great job, I'm going in the morning.
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2010
- Messages
- 5,362
- Reaction score
- 5,115
I shoot several muskets and use minie balls, for me my most accurate load is 60grs fffg with a 500gr Lyman minie. . It'll shoot under 3 moa all day.
I think many use WAY MORE powder than is needed for iron sights.
My best friend uses 50grs fffg in his 54 with prb, has nothing but pass through shots.
HighUintas
45 Cal.
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2022
- Messages
- 516
- Reaction score
- 579
True. For this trip, I'd rather use less because I don't need a lot of range but I think 125gr might be most accurate so far.
ckwilli
36 Cl.
Nice! Thanks for sharing with us
Similar threads
