• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

"Fake" Case Coloring

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

arcticap

54 Cal.
Joined
May 20, 2005
Messages
2,656
Reaction score
640
Location
Central Connecticut
About 10 years ago, I became aquainted with someone who owned a muzzle loader but had never fired a shot with it. So we made arrangements to go to my ML club to do some shooting. He had a Spanish made Kentucky replica and after an afternoon of shooting, I offered to take his rifle home to clean it for him because he didn't have any cleaning equipment or experience.
I used a wood handled, brass bristled brush to clean the lock plate area of his rifle, just like I usually did to clean stubborn deposits off the case colored lockplate on my rifle. But I soon discovered that I had accidently removed the case coloring from 1/2 of his lockplate! I probably should have realized by the subdued tones of his case coloring that it wasn't authentic case coloring to begin with, but rather only an applied or "fake" case coloring effect. My rifle had never been affected in this way, and I felt really bad about having to tell him about how I botched his cleaning. :redface:
He was very understanding about it all, and told me not to worry about it since he had bought the rifle at a dept. store closout, and that it was a really inexpensive gun.
Thankfully, sometime later, he told me how he had located a kit that he could use to restore the case coloring if he wanted to, but that he just might apply bluing to the lockplate instead.
As the saying goes, hindsight is 20/20, and I learned that I should have used a nylon bristled brush instead of a brass one if anything really needed brushing.
It was a lesson learned that I decide to pass on here. I don't recall seeing another gun with "fake" case coloring, but if the lesson helps to prevent someone else from making a similiar mistake, then it's been worth letting y'all know about it. :winking:
 
Thanks for the info. :)

I can't say I've ever seen fake color used like that but there's a lot I haven't seen. It almost sounds like it was some sort of translucient paint.

I might add that any color other than the browning or blueing used on guns is only a light surface discoloration that is easily damaged. This includes real "color case hardening".
 
A cheap semi-color finish could be applied by heating the polished metal object in the oven (say 450) for 1/2 hour and then applying one coat of cold blue. It's not like the real thing but it's OK.
 
Fake case coloring can be done with oil and a propane torch with a "fan" head.

Totally degrease the parts to be case colored, then lightly smear a light oil (like RemOil) on the parts to be colored (just a few drops will do).

Hold the torch about 1" from the metal, without moving, for about 20 - 30 seconds, until heat rings appear (indicating surface color change).

Repeat the process at intervals of about 2" untill all oil has been evaporated.

Before the parts hafe completely cooled (warm to touch) apply another thin coat of oil.

Lightly buff with fine Steel Wool and wipe off with clean towel.

Obviously, keep the heat away from springs.

Practice on some old metal first, but it works fairly well and is super easy.
 
WD 40 does a nice job over a gas cook stove. My dad "tempered" the first tomahawk he made me over our kitchen stove. Thankfully my mother is very understanding. :thumbsup:

App
 
PS Obviously it wasm't sprayed on around the stove or we would have had a major catastrophe! :shocked2:
 
This case coloring looked hazy and was very drab looking. It could have been a dye, since it came off so easily and was applied so thinly on to the surface.
If you ever see such a funky, drab case coloring, I think you'll recognize it from my description.
The rifle came from a Northeast chain store named "Caldor", someone else must have run in to one somewhere along the way. It had a drab looking stock too, not brown but maybe more of a greyish/green?
BTW, my friend (Dale) ended up buying one of those long Pedersoli Blue Ridge Penn. style rifles from Cabela's not very long afterward, so he must have enjoyed shooting. At least there was a "silver lining". :winking:
 
app - if your dad had sprayed the WD-40 around an open flame, two things would have happened:

1) As a child you'd probably jump with glee at the sight of a flamethrower. I would have and use to use deodorants as flamethrowers.

2) You mom would have scalped your father for that stunt and you'd be an ophan.

Thankfully, besides being a wonderful dad who was was nice enough to give his kid a tomahawk (mine didn't), your father was wise enough not to spray over the stove and wasn't scalped. Kudos to your dad!
 
case003.jpg

This lock was "Colored" using a small propane torch, oil and a bright light.

The bright light was to allow me to see the colors changing so I could drop it into a pan of oil to stop at the color I wanted.

I did not leave the cooling oil on the lock when I did the adjacent areas because I didn't need my wife to come storming in yelling "ARE YOU TRYING TO BURN DOWN THE HOUSE???"

The darker areas were the focus of the torch flame with the purples, browns and yellows being further from the heat.
I probably should have been less hasty in my cooling so it would have had more of the blue areas but, it is good enough for me as it is.

As I mentioned before, these colors are very thin and would not take brushing with a wire brush.
On the other hand, this was done several years ago and it is still looking as good as it did when it was done. :)
 

Latest posts

Back
Top