Is it true ..., that they look more like an English fowler than a tradegun? ..., a friend is after an english fowler and we were dicusing changing a pedersoli tradegun to suit .
I'd have to say yes, sorta. I have one, and the butt plate is screwed on, and the side plate is incorrect, as is the blued trigger guard. The barrel is octagon to round, and is browned, and the ramrod pipes were incorrectly drilled and pinned with one pin simply breaking out of the wood. (So much for those that claim that Pedersoli guns are of superior cosmetic quality.)
I have considered swapping out the lock plate to a more correct one, and swapping out the trigger guard to a brass one closer to a Carolina trade gun or English fowler. The screws on the butt plate will need to be removed and unblued, and the browning needs to come off of the barrel.
With those cosmetic changes the gun will look a lot
closer to an English gun. I'd say that your friend will probably want to add an entry thimble, so replacing the two from Pederoli would be needed to to match the after market entry thimble that was bought. The butt plate could be improved by fitting it with a more "English" one. I don't mind the look of the lock but the case hardening color would need to be polished off.
As for functioning, the gun works quite well.
Brand new the kits from Dixie go for $875. I bought mine used for less than half that, so the cost of swapping out several of the parts would still put me below the cost of the kit. Swapping out the butt plate, fitting the new trigger guard, and installing the entry pipe are a tad higher on a skill level than simply putting together a Dixie kit, or finishing the wood of a gun bought in-the-white.
AND consider, with all of those changes, the gun would only be "closer", but it will not be as good as something like this
Pennsylvania Smooth Rifle or this
Virginia Smooth Rifle finished in-the-white, in my opinion. These essentially require the same skill to complete the stock as does a Pedersoli kit, but I think the lock and trigger are higher quality, and the barrel probably is as well. You will need to polish the metal, both the brass and the lock & barrel, but for the finished results and the
cost of the "kit", in my opinion it's worth that added effort.
I would recommend that your friend consider one of the Sitting Fox smooth rifles in something like the 24 bore (.58), or the more common 20 gauge in-the-white. The 20 gauge is more common than the 24 gauge so wads and cards may be easier to find, and the 20 should only weigh a few ounces heavier than the 24, but if your friend was thinking of bird shooting as well as squirrels and deer, he might consider the slightly lighter barrel of the 24 bore, and order it in a 36" barreled gun. A few ounces does make a big difference when swinging the gun on a flying bird. The Sitting Fox guns that I have seen are very nice, and I am currently saving up to get one myself, 24 gauge.
LD