no sir they rifled barrels for ease of loading after multiple shots, the first rifled barrels were straight rifled. the twist was added later and was found to be more accurate.
Rifle vs. Smoothbore
- Thread starter shaman
- Start date
Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:
I have one that is bone stock as it came from from the factory except for the rear sight. if i do my part it will hold a 3" group at 100 yds it's a percussion. i personally have never seen a flint version or a catalog page offering one, so when i wanted to compete in the NMLRA smooth bore class i had to modify one i bought a hunter version and replaced the lock with the l&r flint ( don't even get me started about that lock) removed the rear sight and machined off the snail breech ( the easiest way to convert to flint ) drilled and taped the existing fire channel to accept a t/c touch hole liner
and then started the work training my self to shoot with out a rear sight still working on it !!!!!!! 20 years later.
ronaldrothb49
45 Cal.
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2021
- Messages
- 853
- Reaction score
- 1,462
How far a rifle can accurately shoot number one depends on YOU and number two on the load development for that rifle. Any rifle I have ever owned will shoot a 1 inch group at 50 yards. Once you get that then the human factor takes over. Then it becomes does the rifle fit you or are you doing something that affects the accuracy. All of my rifles except the first one I have made to fit me because the average that production rifles are made to do not fit me, LOP, drop at the comb, the balance point and cast off in the stock can all effect how you can shoot offhand. A good thing to do is ask a friend to observe you shooting and then get feedback from them on what they see.
Smoothbores with 'regulated' barrel can be accurate !
This Fusil has won several 50yd rifle matches.
Back when I was building custom Fusils I 'regulated' the barrel on my personal display gun where the centered decorative notch in the tang aligns perfectly with tip of the turtle front sight blade.
At 82 with bone loss & severed rotator cuff I can no longer shoot long guns so will be posting it for sale on the forum later this month.
Relic shooter
This Fusil has won several 50yd rifle matches.
Back when I was building custom Fusils I 'regulated' the barrel on my personal display gun where the centered decorative notch in the tang aligns perfectly with tip of the turtle front sight blade.
At 82 with bone loss & severed rotator cuff I can no longer shoot long guns so will be posting it for sale on the forum later this month.
Relic shooter
Attachments
For deer I what I use. {{trad. only ( no "inline"
Rifles - Flintlock * 54 cal
Picture #1 = Petersoli Jager (use in brush & dense wooded areas { ease of carry } 50 -75 yd.s
Picture #2 = Petersoli Mortimer ( open aeras ) 75 - 200 yd.s
Smoothbore - Flintlock 12ga
(Have but not for Deer IMHO)
Pictuer #3 = Petersoli Mortimer * {w/ball - 50 yd.s - w/buckshot - 20-25 yd.s
***NOTE*** Flintlock vs Cap Lock
Cap locks are easier to use (learing Curve)- they will use "fake
BP"-more reliable - Less "flash"distraction
Flintlocks harder learning curve - must usereal BP not "fake" - less reliable (striker & frizen) - Flints (loose,dull,chipped,etc)- More Flash distraction (causing flitching)
BTW = The Jager & Mortimer are avail. as caplocks.
Rifles - Flintlock * 54 cal
Picture #1 = Petersoli Jager (use in brush & dense wooded areas { ease of carry } 50 -75 yd.s
Picture #2 = Petersoli Mortimer ( open aeras ) 75 - 200 yd.s
Smoothbore - Flintlock 12ga
(Have but not for Deer IMHO)
Pictuer #3 = Petersoli Mortimer * {w/ball - 50 yd.s - w/buckshot - 20-25 yd.s
***NOTE*** Flintlock vs Cap Lock
Cap locks are easier to use (learing Curve)- they will use "fake
BP"-more reliable - Less "flash"distraction
Flintlocks harder learning curve - must usereal BP not "fake" - less reliable (striker & frizen) - Flints (loose,dull,chipped,etc)- More Flash distraction (causing flitching)
BTW = The Jager & Mortimer are avail. as caplocks.
Attachments
Last edited:
A Pedersoli 58x12 gauge double barrel is for sale on this site now for $1000 if you are interested it is percussion should fit your needs very well
The OP said he wanted a flintlock.
- Joined
- May 6, 2013
- Messages
- 4,340
- Reaction score
- 10,025
Oh yeah .... If you ever want to build a NW trade gun just PM me and I'll send you a building manual , via email , to do so . Be a great project and save you lots of $ ....
did you happen to see the part where I said IF YOU ARE INTERESTED 0r did you overlook that part
No, I didn't. I think you overlooked the entire OP. The OP's premise is already that he wasn't interested in percussion.
Well seems he said he was also interested in a combo gun and he did not say that he wasn't interested in a percussion gun .I was not suggesting he overlook his desire for a Flintlock but that he may be wanting to scratch the combo gun itch . So i am thru with you and will not entertain you or your post any longer so reframe from commenting on or about my comments in the future. That is what happens when you try to be helpful some one else wants to butt in with a smart comment Good Day
shaman
40 Cal
For now, I will stick with flint.
Well, I hit a brick wall today. The guy who runs the Gerstäcker Museum does not have any of Gerstäcker's original firearms. I'll have to go with what I can glean from his writings. We'll save that for another day and another thread.
Back to my original question. Given the same firearms, and the only difference was one was rifled and one was not, how much usuable range would a fellow be able to gain from the rifled barrel? Let's make this even easier: Let's make it a .54 cal Kibler Woodsrunner on whitetail deer.
Well, I hit a brick wall today. The guy who runs the Gerstäcker Museum does not have any of Gerstäcker's original firearms. I'll have to go with what I can glean from his writings. We'll save that for another day and another thread.
Back to my original question. Given the same firearms, and the only difference was one was rifled and one was not, how much usuable range would a fellow be able to gain from the rifled barrel? Let's make this even easier: Let's make it a .54 cal Kibler Woodsrunner on whitetail deer.
- Joined
- Sep 26, 2012
- Messages
- 927
- Reaction score
- 1,276
I grew up hunting deer with a modern smoothbore shotgun with interchangeable chokes. Logic says shooting slugs you want less choke, same with round balls (ML'ers). However my shotgun shot slugs much better with a modified choke tube than it did with cylinder, or improved cylinder chokes. But in the same respect it shot worse with a full choke tube installed. Just goes to show nothing is certain and each gun is different.
50 yards with smoothbore. 100 with rifle. Not all shots are broadside in the open.
Folks haven't mentioned, how well do you see at 100 yards? Are you using an optic on that modern version of a rifle that shoots black powder? I know of a fellow who is an amazing shot with a fowler out to 80 yards, but he also has amazing eyesight.
While yes terrain is a big factor in some choosing a smoothbore over a rifle, eyesight is also part of the equation. Having a rifle that will reach 100+ yards with accuracy, from the bench, is not the same when one's years get advanced, and the eyes won't let the shooter exploit the rifle's capability, eh?
You might also like this, The Still Hunter, by Van Dyke. Although he uses a modern cartridge rifle, the hunting principles and methods are the same for us, especially on moving through the woods.
Gertaker used something like this, eh?
"Paints-His-Shirt-Red" from Jeremiah Johnson
LD
In my opinion, anything smaller than 24 bore in a smoothbore is a waste. No gain for round ball, not enough payload for shotgun.
Wiscoaster your statement is interesting.. I know several people who shoot in lines at 100 yards who have consistent 5 shot groups under 2 inches. Plus theirs people who can do better than that at a lot farther. Just saying but none the less you are shooting very well.
shaman
40 Cal
With my LHR Redemption, that's about what I'm getting. I know I could keep pushing it, but that's all i really need under my current circumstances. I shoot Lee cast R.E.A.L. over Triple 7.
I would note that rifles would become THE gun for American frontiesman. However while the white mountain men were chasing beaver the Metis were building an economy on pemmican production. Almost all was buffalo pemmican. And they stayed loyal to smoothies
Levin, an HBC official providing a guide for HBC would be managers in 1847 poh-pohed rifles. Telling fairly well to do whites to get a smoothbore, as with PRB it shot as well as a rifle to sixty yards and that was enough range for hunting.
A rifle of course can easily produce two inch groups at that range and smoothies won’t generally group as well. However you don’t need two inch groups to put meat on the table. A six even eight inch group will easily drop deer or elk, and just a bit tighter will bring down a buff with one shot
Before 1900 I would hazzard lots more game was killed by smoothies then rifles
Levin, an HBC official providing a guide for HBC would be managers in 1847 poh-pohed rifles. Telling fairly well to do whites to get a smoothbore, as with PRB it shot as well as a rifle to sixty yards and that was enough range for hunting.
A rifle of course can easily produce two inch groups at that range and smoothies won’t generally group as well. However you don’t need two inch groups to put meat on the table. A six even eight inch group will easily drop deer or elk, and just a bit tighter will bring down a buff with one shot
Before 1900 I would hazzard lots more game was killed by smoothies then rifles
By the by Levin said ball in the end of the fingers of worn out gloves. I’m thinking ten shots would be used faster then one wore out gloves so would hazzard thin leather or cloth was the most common patching
Similar threads
