use HUTS to smooth out the finish, it will get very highly glossed and very very even and smooth. then use pumice powder to cut back the gloss. it wont take much rubbing from the pumice powder on a cotton cloth with furniture oil to cut back the gloss. if you have only used watco oil and no varnish over the top of that it wont get the extreme gloss anyways. just a smooth soft glow like a well made piece of furniture. keep us posted.