Here is my narrative on the build from a novice's perspective, and it will be long:
I really didn't know what to expect when I decided I wanted to build a black powder rifle other than I wanted something represented during the Civil War.
I have a Pietta 1858 new Army revolver that I've had for 8-9 years that I enjoy shooting more than my "modern" pistols. I think it's because you have to work at it to shoot it. Rather than just loading up a magazine and pulling the trigger.
Anyway, since this was going to be my first rifle I thought I'd like a black powder, to follow along the same mentality I have with the Pietta.
I had no idea what a good kit is, or a bad one for that matter.
I do know that there are virtually no kits, or assembled reproduction Springfield's or Enfield's in 58 caliber to be had. Those are the only two I was interested in, and I wanted a kit.
Except Deer Creek. They had a Traditions 3 band Enfield kit. Ordered it, along with a Birchwood Casey Deluxe finishing kit. They shipped right away,
and as I said in the second post, it arrived unmolested.
If you have read the posts above you will have a pretty good idea of what went on and how I did things, so I won't rehash them here.
In summary I would call this an entry level kit. Most of the woodwork is generally done as much as you would expect. The barrel channel is for the most part done. There is some minor inletting needing to be done to get the lock in place, the mechanicals away from the wood, as well as the three shoulders for the barrel bands, fore end cap, butt plate, but anyone with any wood working experience should have no issues.
I had zero experience with bluing a barrel, using Tru Oil and what was needed for prep other than Birchwood Casey's instructions. In hindsight, I probably OVER prepped everything. I sanded the stock to 400 grit, used a straightedge to make sure I wasn't distorting the shape. Pretty much the same for the barrel, except the straight edge part. I took it to a 400 grit and then used 0000 steel wool. All of the brass work was done starting with various files, then progressively finer sand paper. Also to 400 grit paper, then 600 grit sponge pad and ultimately 0000 steel wool.
I followed the Birchwood Casey instructions for the Tru Oil, and the Bluing process. The stock has 4 coats of Tru Oil rubbed down with steel wool between each coat. Final coat has been rubbed down with 0000 steel wool then buffed with a terry cloth. I'll see in a week if I will wax the stock or use the stuff that came in the kit. The barrel and bands (once the casting lines were removed) were my biggest fear. In the end, totally unfounded. Only thing I will say is that I would not do the rust and bluing remover again on a new un treated barrel. It left mine tiger striped and splotchy, causing me to re sand and steel wool it then degrease again.
In the end what I think is needed with this, or any kit is patience. You can not get in a hurry. There isn't anything on my rifle that was "good enough" Patience is the key. And with patience as the key, preparation is the door. I KNOW I over prepared the stock, and the barrel for that matter. Nowhere did it say to finish anything to 400 grit. I took it upon myself. Yep, took marginally longer maybe, but peace of mind goes a long way.
I have 35-40 hours start to finish and not knowing what I didn't know, and I learned a lot!
It is not a historical representation, I am not a reenactor. I do think I am an enthusiast now. I enjoyed the build, I didn't have issues with the kit, and I know it makes the caps go "pop". Soon we'll see how well it shoots. My heart tells me it will be just fine!