crockett said:
Probably best not to use as a finish. I'm in Florida and tried Tung Oil- never dried out. I can use boiled linseed oil if I put on thin coats.
Question to the Nabobs....
We all assume linseed oil is the period correct finish but when I read old documents it seems varnish is mentioned. Is there documentation on a linseed oil finish or are we just assuming it was used?
It all depends on the gunsmith, where he worked and especially how much the gun cost.
Probably THE most basic/cheap gun finish was just rubbing in melted beeswax.
Next up from the bottom basic/cheap finish probably was asphaltum first and followed by beeswax. Here is an example of that finish by the late Gary Brumfield who was the Master of the Gun Shop at Colonial Williamsburg after Wallace Gusler.
http://flintriflesmith.com/GunsSince1990/2002_rifle.htm
Now, when they used linseed oil, they did not leave it raw and actually added driers and resins to it to make it into varnish. This of course was more expensive, though it gave both a more pleasing look and was better protection than just beeswax. Eric Kettenburg has done the most research on it, so I am posting a linl to his article.
http://www.muzzleblasts.com/archives/vol5no2/articles/mbo52-1.shtml
Capt. Cuthbertson mentions using varnish on British Brown Bess Gun stocks and even dying them brown, yellow and red - before it, to give them a more military look. This was published first just after the French and Indian War and before the AWI.
Now, CONTRARY to the belief of some folks, the best quality guns got many coats of this varnish and could look like shiny glass over the surface. Many people would think this too shiny, but it surely was done in the 18th and 19th centuries.
BTW, the chemical compounds in Birchwood Casey's Tru Oil are VERY close to period varnish, though it doesn't have lead like many of the old finishes have. One can use that and have shiny finish or knock it back with different types of Scotch Brite pads for a softer/mellower look.
Gus
Edited to add: Well, IF they could not get beeswax and they wanted to stay cheap, they may have used real raw/plain linseed oil alone, but I doubt they used it much as it takes so long to dry.