I would actually trust Lodgewood in the extent that they have an established, obviously stable business with many people involved and a physical address. And they've been around forever. I feel like they won't hold my gun for 3 years or decide to just fold up and keep everyone's stuff. But nothing is 100%
A single person who provides vague location info or a PO Box , even though they have a good reputation , is basically just saying that he's a home gunsmith who doesn't want face to face customers, and would rather just work on your stuff, take your $$ and ship back, rinse and repeat. There's a lot of them out there. They don't want to sit down with you and go over what you want done , over a cup of Jack and coffee or something, they'd rather just exchange emails. Which is whatever, but you have no idea where your property is or when you're getting it back.
I'll just continue to keep my own stuff running