roaddog: Love the hair dude!!!
This topic is almost as controversial as "ta swab 'er not ta swab?".
I personally like the M.A.P. otherwise known as Murphy's Oil Soap, Alcohol (rubbing 91%) and Peroxide( drug store variet 3% solution ). 2 parts alcohol, one Murphy's, one, peroxide. Four wet patches will completely disolve all black powder fouling.
There is a caveat to this however.
You MUST get all the MAP out as the peroxide is itself an oxidant and it WILL rust your barrel.
You must run at least two rubbing alcohol patches down bore after you use MAP, then dry patch, then oil, Bore Butter, whatever.
Ordinary rubbing alcohol has a unique property.
It absorbs water.
It will cut the soap and peroxide out of the lands and grooves and after you dry patch you are ready to oil or whatever you do to prevent rust when the arm is stored.
I always alcohol wipe the barrel before I get rady to shoot, following once again with a dry patch.
Be advised MANY people will not use MAP at all because the peroxide is an oxidizer. Birddog6 won't use it and warns against it.
I have never had a problem and have used it for 3 years., but I see why people shy away from it.
I personally feel T/C bore cleaner a waste of money when there are so many formulas that work well such as Simple Green and water, vinegar ( an acid) and water, soap and water, plain cold water, etc. etc.
I fired my blue steel Pietta .44 18 rounds with black 3fg, sprayed it with RemOil and let her set for 3 weeks inspecting daily for corrosion. Weren't none. I finally cleaned the thing properly and concluded that you could spray your gun down and not clean it for several days at least with no rust forming.
No I would NOT do that to my custom flinters!