36 caliber deer hunting

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
...I'm not here to judge anyone. I personally would not take a .36 PRB deer hunting...
Me either, GSML. Now, starving to death in an apocalypse situation I'd shoot spitballs at 'em if that's all I had....

ETA: Uh-oh, just saw Loyalist Dave's post. Is a spitball too modern? I promise I won't mention them again.
 
The .36 killed A LOT of men. It was considered very capable in that role. The .44 was designed to kill Horses.

I don’t understand all the hand wringing about using a .36 launched from a rifle to kill deer at reasonable ranges.

Muzzleloaders don’t kill with “energy”, they kill by punching holes in things, and the .36 round ball correctly applied to the side of a deer will do just that.

I love my .58’s and .62’s…but having killed lots of stuff with them and my .40’s…I really don’t see much difference in the way deer-sized game reacts. We have Magnumized ourselves into thinking that unless you dump atom-splitting levels of energy into a whitetail deer it just won’t die.

If it will reliably kill a man, it will work on a deer.
 
Last edited:
.45 and bigger here in Nebraska. If i could i still wouldn't just because deer can get huge here and i wouldn't feel comfortable shooting a big one with a .36, even with a maxi within 50 yards.

36 maxi does exist, but they and the molds are very rare. I've also tried the paper patched .357 158 gr option and got keyholes at 25 yds with my Seneca but the maxi shot under 4 inch at 50.
Also, accurate does have a pretty much identical mold.View attachment 354673
View attachment 354672
I am one of those fortunate souls that has a set of T-C Maxi-Ball mold blocks. I have not used them yet. They were in a box of miscellaneous muzzleloader stuff the widow of a good friend of mine sold to me cheap after he died. I didn’t even know the mold blocks were in the box until I went thru it 3 years or so later. Nice surprise!
 
I am one of those fortunate souls that has a set of T-C Maxi-Ball mold blocks. I have not used them yet. They were in a box of miscellaneous muzzleloader stuff the widow of a good friend of mine sold to me cheap after he died. I didn’t even know the mold blocks were in the box until I went thru it 3 years or so later. Nice surprise!
 
45 caliber is the legal minimum here. Could it be done with a 36, yes because it can be done with a 22LR behind the ear
 
Back
Top