Imported Guns Are Junk

[Walkabout]

So says this guy I watched on YouTube last night. He said essentially, that the locks on imported factory built flintlocks are made poorly and it's pure luck to find one that functions properly. He also stated that the only way to get a lock that works consistently, is to have it custom made. What say you?

 

[Steve Martin]

Semi-true. Nothing usually works as well as something custom made by a professional but, are all factory made locks junk? No. People that make blanket statements like what you saw on Youtube usually have very little first-hand experience or they would not make such statements to begin with. Those of us that have actually owned, shot and worked on flintlocks of our own know that there are always locks that are great right out of the box, some that are ok, with a little adjusting and some that are a lost cause right off the bat but that can be said about almost anything.

 

[Omahkapi'si]

Sorry don’t have time to get into it, too busy shooting my Pedersolis.

 

[deerstalkert]

wonder if he drives a Toyota or Datsun.
OOPS! dated myself
there are so many imported guns that his argument is silly! there are good imported locks and great customs, just as there are good Yugo's and there are Roll's Royce.

 

[granth]

So says this guy I watched on YouTube last night. He said essentially, that the locks on imported factory built flintlocks are made poorly and it's pure luck to find one that functions properly. He also stated that the only way to get a lock that works consistently, is to have it custom made. What say you?

At a recent shoot I attended, I shot two Traditions guns and an Investarms gun. Traditions is imported from Spain and Investarms is imported from Italy. The locks on these guns worked flawlessly with no issues (both flint and percussion). It seems like a gross overgeneralization to call all imported locks junk in my eyes .

 

[Kansas Jake]

That’s like saying all Fords are great and all Volkswagens are junk. Both have made great vehicles and both have had junk. Even the great ones occasionally had a lemon amidst diamonds.

 

[SDSmlf]

So says this guy I watched on YouTube last night.

A lot of guys on YouTube saying a lot of stuff. Might you let us know which expert you were watching?

 

[S.Kenton]

I have a couple of pedersolis… both are Awsome consistant shooters.. I’ve shot Traditions as well.. no issues. Typical internet opinions..

 

[hunter thompson]

I HAD A TRADITIONS trapper and after 500 shots there wasnt any rifling in the last 4 inches of the barrel..SOFT STEEL these companys from guawanda land used. Lesser quality on barrels /parts ect..

 

[doubleset]

People that make blanket statements like what you saw on Youtube usually have very little first-hand experience or they would not make such statements to begin with.

Or they're trying to sell you an alternative.

 

[azmntman]

I own only production and all my meat has been unimpressed with his opinion.

 

[deerstalkert]

i have two locks that are not production. a Haddaway and a Siler. both are wonderful locks.
i have 3 imported locks. setup correctly and they work just like the "higher quality" ones.
i have a investarms that hasn't misfired in 200 shots. my Mortimer has never not fired. my Ardesa has never not fired.
and the beat goes on.......................

 

[Robby]

Kinda like, the internet is mostly junk.
Robby

 

[dave951]

It's Utoob. Why the surprise?

 

[springfield art]

Semi-true. Nothing usually works as well as something custom made by a professional but, are all factory made locks junk? No. People that make blanket statements like what you saw on Youtube usually have very little first-hand experience or they would not make such statements to begin with. Those of us that have actually owned, shot and worked on flintlocks of our own know that there are always locks that are great right out of the box, some that are ok, with a little adjusting and some that are a lost cause right off the bat but that can be said about almost anything.

Very good 'on point' comments! Most will agree with you completely.

 

[dave951]

Well since all imports are junk, I'll help out in eliminating this scourge by offering $2 for each Parker Hale. Just tryin to do my part here......

 

[Feltwad]

There is know doubt that there is a big difference in workmanship between a repro and a original , for me it has always been originals mainly because they was no reproes 74 years ago when I bought my first and the originals were a reasonable price but they were English made of course
Feltwad
My first M/L gun bought 74 years ago for the sum of 7 shilling sterling

 

[IronHand]

Since almost all production bp guns are made overseas you would think more people would be talking about this, if it were true.

This kind of hate is usually reserved for guns made in India. That's a whole different subject but the 2 India guns I have do not agree with your You Tube ****.

IronHand

 

[tenngun]

Cheaper flintlocks on imported guns can be poor, but I had a Davis that was crap , and Long triggers that were put together by monkeys. I’ve heard folk complain about L and R, but I never had trouble with them. Davis and Long stood by their work.
I’ve seen several curry poppers I would be proud to own.
I drink mostly beer. I do like a good Chianti an Pinot. Had them imported and domestic. Cant say one is ‘better’ then the other
Same with cheese.
I’ll tell this boy any foreign gun he doesn’t like he can send to me.

 

[Walkabout]

A lot of guys on YouTube saying a lot of stuff. Might you let us know which expert you were watching?

It's the Traditional Muzzleloaders channel. Flintlocks-The secrets they don't want you to know.