Bill,
You are absolutely right! We should always strive for perfection and total accuracy, but realize we won't always get there. that's why I strive to follow the spirit of the laws. There is always so much room for improvement in everything we do. Sure I could dump my non-period stuff like my blue chip enamel, my boxes with brass plated hardware, half the untensils I fill those boxes with, and I could change out my TC coil spring lock to a v-spring lock.
As long as the person is always striving to perfect his gear and at least follow the spirit of the rules (unless its a juried event), I can overlook a lot of small details.
Besides most officials at rondys overlook those kind of items and there are always accepted items at most rondys that are not and never have been correct. No I don't include inlines in that category of being correct!
As to sidelock plastic stocks, they certainly would not be my first choice or second or third. But they do offer someone who wants to try the sport without investing a large amount of cash in it. I honestly don't know anyone who owns one and has kept it as his primary rifle. I believe anybody who stays with BP will upgrade their rifle as soon as financially possible.
Sorry Bill I just seem to keep running off at the mouth...eh fingers!
Smokeydays