• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Open tops are just sexy

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Don't forget the LeMat!
LeMat Percussion Revolver (2).JPG

Or the Webley Longspur.
Webley Longspur (3).JPG
 
I'm not convinced of that the Remingtons were any stronger.
I think that's a misnomer... I agree... the "stronger" bit is really the removal of the pins that hold the barrel onto the receiver, and thus there will be no possible "bending" or "stretching" from stout loads, because the Remington frame is a square.

LD
 
For typical powder charges I suspect the 'stronger' Remington style doesn't matter. And both types will do fine as long as the round balls are sufficiently pure and not oversized. It does make it quicker and easier to swap out a cylinder compared to the Colt.

But dang!! The open top Colts look good.

Jeff
 
For typical powder charges I suspect the 'stronger' Remington style doesn't matter. And both types will do fine as long as the round balls are sufficiently pure and not oversized. It does make it quicker and easier to swap out a cylinder compared to the Colt.

But dang!! The open top Colts look good.

Jeff
This pistol is 60 years old. It’s never been babied, shot nothing but full charges of 3f goex, Swiss or triple 7 under round ball or bullets up to 245 grains weight. I shoot this one a lot and always have. There’s no evidence of stretching or shooting loose, the bolt/trigger spring, hand spring, and mainspring have all been replaced at least once. The hand was replaced once, the wedge and arbor have been case hardened, and the chambers are reamed to .456” to shoot .458 bullets and .460” round ball. My youngest granddaughter will inherit this one and I fully expect it to last her lifetime too. How much stronger should a revolver be?
1644459015361.jpeg
 
This pistol is 60 years old. It’s never been babied, shot nothing but full charges of 3f goex, Swiss or triple 7 under round ball or bullets up to 245 grains weight. I shoot this one a lot and always have. There’s no evidence of stretching or shooting loose, the bolt/trigger spring, hand spring, and mainspring have all been replaced at least once. The hand was replaced once, the wedge and arbor have been case hardened, and the chambers are reamed to .456” to shoot .458 bullets and .460” round ball. My youngest granddaughter will inherit this one and I fully expect it to last her lifetime too. How much stronger should a revolver be?
View attachment 120950

That revolver has that "been there, done that" look to it! That one needs to go to someone who will appreciate it.
 
I concur! I would much rather be seen with an open top colt in the holster. I love the remmys but as far as point ability sleekness and class the open top colts are second to none! Here is my favorite open top, 72 uberti!
 

Attachments

  • FFB20AE6-4D01-43D5-982E-0AF92CADE672.jpeg
    FFB20AE6-4D01-43D5-982E-0AF92CADE672.jpeg
    81.6 KB
  • 77AAC105-FE5C-4BDC-987E-762EEB669C60.jpeg
    77AAC105-FE5C-4BDC-987E-762EEB669C60.jpeg
    71.2 KB
  • 8C28E1A2-2C2C-4370-8652-5573E77B44C0.jpeg
    8C28E1A2-2C2C-4370-8652-5573E77B44C0.jpeg
    52.7 KB
  • CC9B9078-610D-44D4-90DB-29278E5ADD8F.jpeg
    CC9B9078-610D-44D4-90DB-29278E5ADD8F.jpeg
    83.9 KB
  • 84195EC2-066D-4FFB-8ABB-CACFC0773FB4.jpeg
    84195EC2-066D-4FFB-8ABB-CACFC0773FB4.jpeg
    75.8 KB
I concur! I would much rather be seen with an open top colt in the holster. I love the remmys but as far as point ability sleekness and class the open top colts are second to none! Here is my favorite open top, 72 uberti!

The 1860 model Colts were nothing short of elegant, yet purposeful and deadly.
IMHO Sam Colt's masterpiece was the 1860 Model in .44
 
Back
Top