Uberti pock mark in frame

[oldschoolhunter55]

Haa!!! Like this one?
View attachment 347299

I'm working on this one right now!!! There's absolutely nothing to worry about. It's a "break through" from machining the hand channel.

No need to "send it back"!!! Lol

Mike

gosh dang. I seen that picture and took off to my gun safes. took my revolvers out and checked them lol. thanks Mike for giving me peace of mind. thanks bud

 

[lone pine]

the pit is a smidgen less than 1/2" at its deepest part. just want to make I understand correctly. where exactly does it end and is there a shape/depth/end location that is acceptable?. rather ask a dumb question than not know.

 

[Tenring]

Its an Italian BP Pistol and it comes wițh the territory, I have a couple USA Colt Single actions and if you seen the little imperfections in those you would manure yourself, Nothing is ever the way we would like it to be especially from Taylor’s I have had words with them in the past.

 

[lone pine]

thx for reply. at least I can know what to expect.

lp

 

[AlexB]

thx for reply. at least I can know what to expect.

lp

Think of them as nearly finished kits........it helps.

 

[lone pine]

bummer. still - thx for setting that out there.

 

[M. De Land]

sure think it's a handy place to collect more fouling.

Yeah, that's a doozy of a void thinking on it some more as it is actually above the chimney channel in the frame cheek where it should be solid steel. It's still not any where that would be a strength issue though.

 

[wiscoaster]

sorry, deleted.

 

[lone pine]

well I lost my case with taylor's. they're just sending back the Whitney with the breakthrough imperfection in the frame. basically they said it wasn't a fatal flaw and was safe to shoot (as mr. 45 D already said). it's like having a car with hail damage. unhappy.
lp

 

[lone pine]

Alex b - yes. I had dropped some bucks with them on guns already and was hoping for a better outcome.

lp

 

[lone pine]

for the metallurgy guys her -
what I wanted to ask in all ignorance was:
could that breakthrough be filled with something like some type of solder or:
- even degreased and some grade of bismuth hammered in to fill it?

thanks
lp

 

[KingOfKindling]

for the metallurgy guys her -
what I wanted to ask in all ignorance was:
could that breakthrough be filled with something like some type of solder or:
- even degreased and some grade of bismuth hammered in to fill it?

thanks
lp

Sure, as long as you don't fill in the area behind where it broke through. That cavity behind the breakthrough was cut on purpose. It's where the hand spring rides. There's just a paper thin bit of metal in that area.

If it bugs you that much, why not file up to the break. I've got several guns where the notch is open nearly all the way to the top.

 

[lone pine]

*here

 

[45D]

for the metallurgy guys her -
what I wanted to ask in all ignorance was:
could that breakthrough be filled with something like some type of solder or:
- even degreased and some grade of bismuth hammered in to fill it?

thanks
lp

Honestly, it's not a void or flaw (even though it keeps being mentioned as). If you "zoom in", you can see what they should look like. It's totally open all the way.

Mike

 

[hawkeye2]

Worrying about that is sorta like checking your date's teeth before you take her out.

 

[lone pine]

hawkeye2 - yes the logical side of me agrees with you and other members who pointed this out. but I was just miffed about getting an old brood mare rather than the thoroughbred I was expecting.
lp

 

[45D]

To help maybe drive home a point, here's 3 Pietta shop guns -

You don't have an "old brood mare". Two days ago I took my Whitneyville and 1st Mod. to the range and both Dragoons shot 45C +p's just perfectly!! They are strong as an ox!!!

Mike

 

[lone pine]

To help maybe drive home a point, here's 3 Pietta shop guns -
View attachment 353064

You don't have an "old brood mare". Two days ago I took my Whitneyville and 1st Mod. to the range and both Dragoons shot 45C +p's just perfectly!! They are strong as an ox!!!

Mike

 

[lone pine]

it seems to check all the boxes with people who know more than me. going to the range tomorrow. I really appreciate everyone's informed comments. this forum is a nice resource.
lp

 

[Bad Karma]

These are relatively cheap guns but they aren’t free either so it’s understandable that we want them to be closer to perfect. Not to mention they’re so different from modern arms most new users don’t really know what to expect from them. Thank goodness for guys like @45D and others who’ve seen thousands of these guns and can advise us as to what’s normal and what’s not.