• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Regarding Carrying Tomahawks

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Not sure how accurate this may be but this pooped up on a Alamo Facebook group today because it is the anniversary of Stephen Austin's death.

Austin.jpg
 
Not sure how accurate this may be but this pooped up on a Alamo Facebook group today because it is the anniversary of Stephen Austin's death.

View attachment 111450
Artists and photographers commonly used props that they themselves supplied, or at the least positioned. A hatchet or tomahawk carried in that manner is going to cut the person wearing it. Not a matter of, might or maybe, but a matter of fact.
 
I can see where a sheath for a hawk would have its benefits, I have even made a few both a cover just for the blade and a slung one that fully covers the head, but thinking of a frontier situation I doubt not too many hawks,hatchets or what ever were sheathed, as tools that might need too be called into service rather quickly.
 
I would say, then or now, walking around with a sharp tomahawk/hatchet, in your belt unsheathed or unprotected, is about as stupid as walking around with a full cocked pistol in your belt
Ya it’s pretty dumb. I can’t think our forbears didn’t have the brains to sheath their hawks but a sheath for knives is standard. Doesn’t make sense.
 
View attachment 111509
here’s a painting by Bodmer. The gentleman on the far right has a sheathed tomahawk attached to his shoulder bag
That gentleman is the artist himself, Carl (or Karl) Bodmer. The shorter white man standing next to him is Prince Maximillian, his employer and patron. Bodmer is known to have painted with almost photographic realism, and Maximillian demanded accurate representations.

I think you can take that one to the bank...

Notchy Bob
 
That gentleman is the artist himself, Carl (or Karl) Bodmer. The shorter white man standing next to him is Prince Maximillian, his employer and patron. Bodmer is known to have painted with almost photographic realism, and Maximillian demanded accurate representations.

I think you can take that one to the bank...

Notchy Bob
Very cool!
 
I've seen several quotes regarding people carrying tomahawks in their belts. We've now seen a couple of examples of shoulder slung sheaths, so we know they existed.

This quote is from George Frederick Ruxton's lesser known book, Adventures in Mexico and the Rocky Mountains:

Ruxton - Adventures, p. 243.png


Note that he took the trouble to mention the "...large butcher-knife in a sheath of buffalo-hide..." and "...a little buckskin case containing a whetstone..." He didn't say anything about a tomahawk sheath, though. This is not to say the tomahawk was not sheathed, but he did mention sheaths for the other two items.

For certain, I haven't read everything. I have read a lot, though, and I have seen mention of people carrying tomahawks in their belts a couple of times, but I don't recall reading any specific mention of a tomahawk sheath. If it were me, I would probably try to fabricate one using traditional materials and techniques. If nothing else, you could just fold a scrap of buckskin over the cutting edge and wrap a thong to secure it. If our hypothetical trapper had to "whip it out" in a hurry, he probably wouldn't take the time to uncover the blade.

As a parting thought, it is my understanding that most of the surviving native tomahawks of the types that would have been used in battle have blunt, rounded edges. These were used more like clubs than weapons for cutting. However, it would make sense that their camp axes would be sharpened, and I believe Samuel Hearne stated that they used files for this purpose. It would also make sense that the white trappers would sharpen their axes, as the axes would be used for cutting stakes and so forth in setting beaver traps.

Just to add a little to the confusion ...

Notchy Bob
 
Artists and photographers commonly used props that they themselves supplied, or at the least positioned. A hatchet or tomahawk carried in that manner is going to cut the person wearing it. Not a matter of, might or maybe, but a matter of fact.

Of course they did. I cannot recall seeing any Indian artwork with them holding hawks with a sheath. Likewise, a peace pipe is not always carried without cover. Yet we see rifles with and without sheaths, too. We tend to question accuracy at times and then take some as acceptable. And as others mentioned, I cannot recall reading any account where the hawk was unsheathed before it was used, either. Taken for granted? Maybe so. Were pistols loaded and in their belts, too? WE would not do that now, either. Interesting thread and so far a hawk with or without a cover has not been totally questioned.
 
I have a throwing tomahawk and a large throwing knife. My son was into leatherworking for a while, and made a custom baldric with a shoulder strap to carry both, ala these in this depiction of Roger's Rangers. Im not sure of the "historical accuracy " but don't care. It's nice, and will last a lifetime.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20211228-084201_Chrome.jpg
    Screenshot_20211228-084201_Chrome.jpg
    141.1 KB
  • Screenshot_20211228-084632_Gallery.jpg
    Screenshot_20211228-084632_Gallery.jpg
    34.3 KB
It is said that Lord Baltimore the Indian/White Tracker that helped hunt down Butch Cassidy and the Sun Dance Kid Carried a Tomahawk and this was nearing the turn of the century 1900’s wow preety cool.
 
Back
Top