Mike,
I think what they are getting at is when you have paid a few hundred dollars for a rifle (more than once) that paying $1500, $2000 or more that it would be a 'showpiece' rifle to them. I have two rifles, a T/C 'Hawken' that shoots the lights everytime ($150) and I just traded for a Traditions Pennsylvania that sparks really well (can't shoot it yet due to the snow/ice). It brand new would be the way upper end of my pocketbook. I have never seen your work but from your defense of your craft, you are probably very good at what you do. And I do appreciate fine workmanship!!
I think the view here is, if it works and the price is right and just starting out...buy it and learn. The point is not to spend too much now and learn but when you have grown into the hobby start to upgrade. Like buying a Formula one racer to start out in racing. BUT, there are many really good rifles out there at the 500 to 1000 dollar range. Just trying to help everyone see the light.
If you want a reliable flinter check with the locals and the upcoming antique gun shows that are coming up.
Good Luck and have fun!!
(my 2p worth) :v
Cheers, DonK