• Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Pyrodex...will somebody please explain?

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hate to blow all your figures, but I use Swiss.

15% stronger than Goex, and equal to T7.


Besides that. I never talked about what is cheaper. I talked about what is better. The best always costs more. :blah:
 
Are you Pyrodex and Triple 7 haters running out of factual arguments yet?

What "fact"?
All I've seen so far are opinions, and as I've said before, one opinion is as good as another.
Mine is no better than anyone else's, and vice-versa.
Despite the lengthy thread and fanatical arguments, I've seen nothing to make me change my mind... I will continue to buy and use Pyrodex unless something personally convinces me not to. I am quite curious to try out the Holy Black for comparison purposes,(IF I can get it) but my opinions haven't changed after 9 pages of rant. Pyrodex has performed well for me over 25 years.
 
CaptainKirk said:
Are you Pyrodex and Triple 7 haters running out of factual arguments yet?

What "fact"?
All I've seen so far are opinions, and as I've said before, one opinion is as good as another.
Mine is no better than anyone else's, and vice-versa.
Despite the lengthy thread and fanatical arguments, I've seen nothing to make me change my mind... I will continue to buy and use Pyrodex unless something personally convinces me not to. I am quite curious to try out the Holy Black for comparison purposes,(IF I can get it) but my opinions haven't changed after 9 pages of rant. Pyrodex has performed well for me over 25 years.

As our opinions haven't changed either.

Just for the record though. There have been posts saying they had misfires, and others saying they had rust from Crapo.

I saw neither of those for BP.

Some people can't see the evidence if it smacked them upside the head. :idunno:
 
I always respond to posts directed at me.

I don't want to be rude.


See! You made one too.
 
CaptainKirk said:
Are you Pyrodex and Triple 7 haters running out of factual arguments yet?

What "fact"?
All I've seen so far are opinions, and as I've said before, one opinion is as good as another.
Mine is no better than anyone else's, and vice-versa.
Despite the lengthy thread and fanatical arguments, I've seen nothing to make me change my mind... I will continue to buy and use Pyrodex unless something personally convinces me not to. I am quite curious to try out the Holy Black for comparison purposes,(IF I can get it) but my opinions haven't changed after 9 pages of rant. Pyrodex has performed well for me over 25 years.
if you can get it? i've posted twice were you can get it. even at a better price than most places.
 
So, Mr. Capper, what were those posts of yours on 11/20/10 "I pay $111 for 5lbs shipped to my door in 3 days." "Min order is 5lbs at $15 a lb for Goex. $20 for HazMat plus shipping. That comes to $111 for 5lbs for me." So, if you are shooting Swiss, how much does it cost? Are you giving this Goex away as Xmas presents?
 
I shot it all at that price. I then bought 25lbs at $14 lb with free ship and Hazmat.

Swiss is more, but I only use it for hunting. It will last me forever.

Goex is for CAS.
 
Yes, and thanks for that. I have checked into it and I CAN buy it...now...for not much more than the subs. I was speaking metaphorically, in case our politicians give birth to yet another stupid law which restricts shipment to our beloved state.
For the record, my next powder purchase will be BP......
 
CaptainKirk said:
Yes, and thanks for that. I have checked into it and I CAN buy it...now...for not much more than the subs. I was speaking metaphorically, in case our politicians give birth to yet another stupid law which restricts shipment to our beloved state.
For the record, my next powder purchase will be BP......
i'm sure you'll be pleased with your purchase, if not and you buy swiss, i'll take what you don't want.
 
So somebody said they had rust in their bore from shooting Pyrodex? Since my rifles have each shot dozens or some hundreds of rounds with Pyrodex and Triple 7, I decided to closely inspect my bores. I have close copies of orginal rifles I built, and these have been fired hundreds and some thousands of times. They are a .40 Thomas Oldham Bedford caplock, a .40 Jacob Wigle flint, a .45 Green River Rifle Works Leman caplock (I built it in their shop), the two .50 flinters pictured in this thread, a .54 Leman and a .54 Bridger Hawken caplock (also pictured in Percussion forum currently, "scaled down Hawken type rifles"), and a .58 fullstock Hawken flintlock.

I looked down the bores with a Streamlight Stylus LED light (got mine at Radio Shack for about $15). You can see the breech plug. Then I wiped the dust out of the bores and looked again. Some had a dark ring at the corner of the barrel and breech plug, so I made breech plug scrapers to clean that out. Used a piece of 10x32 bolt 3/4" long to thread into my cleaning rod, cut a notch in a piece of flat brass and soldered this over the end of the bolt, and filed it to just slip down the bore, square and sharp. Scraped the fouling out. Soaked the lower bore with my bore cleaner, dried it out, then cleaned the bores with JB bore paste and wiped clean. All bores were bright and clean with no rusting or pitting. I oiled all the bores again. So that is my personal experience with this bore rusting issue.
 
Not bad, only 21 pages this time.

This same olde wore out topic crops it head several times every year since this Forum started back in 03' and it'll come back again next time someone ask's;
"what's the best powder?"

And that happens every week, and will probably happen as long as olde women keep talkin about olde men.
:yakyak: yawn,,,
 
necchi said:
Not bad, only 21 pages this time.

This same olde wore out topic crops it head several times every year since this Forum started back in 03' and it'll come back again next time someone ask's;
"what's the best powder?"

And that happens every week, and will probably happen as long as olde women keep talkin about olde men.
:yakyak: yawn,,,
Didn't stop you from participating, did it? :wink:
One thing about us muzzleloaders...when it comes to yakking up a subject, we just can't seem to shut up! :yakyak:
(Speaking from personal experience!) :hmm:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top